By Heather O.
I know a lot about swallowing. It sounds weird, I know, but swallowing is actually kind of complicated, and, well, kind of important. It’s one of the first instincts that you develop in utero, and it’s one of the first indicators that your life is near its end. I’ve been consulted on a lot of death beds, because when people stop swallowing, they don’t have long to live. It’s just one of those circle of life kind of things.
There are lots of ways to evaluate a person’s swallowing function. When I was in graduate school, I learned about and was trained to do all of them. But my professor, who worked at NIH and knew everything there was about swallowing, also told us about a ‘new’ technique for evaluating swallowing, and she made no bones about the fact that she found it completely ridiculous. It’s called FEES, or Fiber Endoscopic Evaluation of Swallowing. Hence, we learned the basics as she rolled her eyes, and we moved on.
I won’t bore you with details (too late?), but basically this technique involves shoving a tube with a camera on the end of it up someone’s nose, threading it down past their soft palate, and taking pictures of their throat while they swallow. For a variety of reasons this is not the “gold standard” in terms of evaluating swallowing, but I’ve since come to learn it has its place.
I’ve done this procedure once. On a fellow trainee, who then did it on me. I made her nose bleed. It wasn’t pretty.
I’ve had to make judgement calls that were shaky at best based on information I received from others doing this procedure, and I didn’t like it. But I felt okay about my recommendations, because everybody was new at this, and everybody’s judgement calls were shaky at best. We were shaking together, doing the best we knew how for our patients. I hate to break it to y’all, but a lot of time, that’s how medicine works.
This week, I attended a conference about neurological emergencies as part of my continuing education requirements to keep my license as a speech language pathologist. Most of the people there were nurses who worked in a neuro unit. There was a lot of info that I didn’t understand and probably will never use, as it went way out of my own scope of practice. But there was a fair number of speech therapists there, and one therapist was even asked to discuss how she trains nurses in her hospital when it comes to swallowing. She described the process, and then said that most of the patients would need full instrumental evaluation before being allowed to swallow anything. She said that she does FEES at their hospital. And everybody nodded sagely.
It was that moment that I realized something very important.
I’m old. And I’m out of date.
It’s been 2 years since I’ve set foot in a hospital as a professional. At this point, I could not read a FEES eval if someone’s life depended on it, and, unfortunately, sometimes it does. This is the cost of being a SAHM mom.
It’s a tough pill to swallow when you look at women who are your age who you know have better experience than you do, who can offer more to a patient than you can, who are more confident with their skills than you are. It’s a REALLY tough pill to swallow when you see kids right out of grad school who could walk circles around you with their skills, and you are supposed to be the one with experience. And all along, you wonder, “How long can I fake it before somebody notices, or worse, before somebody gets hurt?”
(Another scary thought–I wonder how many doctors feel that way? [shudder])
I love being a SAHM, and my 4 years of struggling to have another child taught me that children are not a given, they are a gift. My days are slow, I don’t get out much, and I spend a lot of time picking up after a toddler who can trash my kitchen in 2.5 seconds. It’s not exactly exciting, but it’s the life I’ve chosen, and most days, I’m really glad I did it.
But it means that I’m old and out of date.
This is not a unique discussion, I know. The choices that we make, by definition, limit our lives, and so we make choices that hopefully give us the life we want. I wanted this life, I chose it, and I don’t take anything for granted. I know it’s not possible to be a full time speech therapist who can solve all the world’s problems and still be the kind of mother I want to be.
But sometimes, just sometimes, I wish that it was.
Thanks for letting me ramble. And my kids are WAY cute. Just so you know.




Yeah. I get you. My profession isn’t nearly as important (no one’s life depends on my artistic skills), but when recently talking about my going back to work, we realized that eight years at home has given me a significant disadvantage.
Technology has moved worlds in the 8 years I’ve been at home; to even get hired for a technical job, I would have to go back to school.
It’s the life I opted for, and I’m not really complaining, but sometimes it’s hard to stand on the platform and watch the train blow by…
Comment #1 by Tracy MOctober 15th, 2008 at 7:06 pmI had no career or life path to give up when we decided to start our family. I still don’t know what I want to be when I “grow up” and my kids move out. I know I’ve got a long time to think about it (my only child thus far is only 6 months old), but I often wish that I already had something in mind, something that I could keep occasionally working on as my children grow, rather than still fluttering about from one interest to another.
I suppose ultimately I don’t really have to have something. I have my Bachelor’s degree, and could get a job if needed. My mother doesn’t have a career, she just does whatever she feels like doing now that her kids are all moved out. It could be nice.
Still, sometimes I wish I’d had something else first, before my job as a mom. Being a mom, though, is definitely the best job I’ve ever had. There’s always something new, and I’m never getting horribly bored like I did at the jobs I’ve had before.
Comment #2 by kaduseyOctober 15th, 2008 at 7:07 pmI loved this post Heather. I DO work, but I primarily freelance and contract, which is mostly great for my home life (MOSTLY - not this week in particular, but generally), but is somewhat limiting professionally and its sometimes incredibly hard to balance and juggle. Sometimes I feel like I’m not being particularly effective at work OR at home.
This week I was approached by a tech company and offered a full-time job in my field at a salary that would have been game changing for us. It was incredibly hard to say no - not just because we need the money, but because it was an opportunity to step up to the next tier professionally. But it would have been full-time and there would have been no flexibility, so I had to turn it down.
I don’t regret making that decision at all - but I sometimes envy how much easier that decision would have been for my husband.
Comment #3 by SueOctober 15th, 2008 at 7:48 pmI hear this often from mothers… and I don’t think it has to be an either/or decision. In our mobile and technological society there is so much we can do for our careers and ourselves while still taking full care of our children. I spend my “Free time” as a childbirth educator in my home and a birth doula… and right now as a student midwife very very part time. I plan to be a homebirth midwife by the time my children can have babies so that I can catch! :}
Comment #4 by bookwormmamaOctober 15th, 2008 at 7:57 pmThis is my passion aside from motherhood and it gives me something to do to keep me being me… something unique and separate from being a mother…I can do this at home and around our family’s schedule as time allows. With 6 kids, that may seem impossible… but because I need it and love it so much… and it makes me a happier Mom, it’s good for the whole family. :} I am not making a ton of money but I am exercising my brain and being a good role model for my children, while working at home and still taking care of their needs first and foremost. And when they are grown and gone, {barring any unforeseen complications} I have a plan for my life {which will hopefully include catching my grandchildren as they come into the world!} :}
Sigh…this post confirms both that my decision was the right one AND my worst fears. I am expecting my first child in February, and my husband and I made the decision a long time ago that I would be a SAHM if at all possible. My pregnancy has been a hard one so I quit work early. I was in politics. I have only been out of the loop 2 short months and already I find myself e-mailing my (old(double-sigh)) colleagues asking about the real story behind one proposiiton or another on the ballot this Nov. I know our decision was the right one and will be rewarding (why else would you right a post like this, but still want to be with your kids at the end of the day), but I already miss the job so much: it’s a complete addiction, like gambling, only not against church policies
I don’t even want to fathom what it will be like 5 years down the road. All my experience will be completely irrelevant, because in politics yesterdays news is old news, let alone last years. It will be like I never even stepped foot in the capitol. The personal sacrifices we make in the name of healthy, happy and spiritually fed children. I just have to keep reminding myself how worth it that is! But really, becoming irrelavent after so much education, long hours, and hard work is a totally depressing thought.
Comment #5 by AlyssaOctober 15th, 2008 at 8:07 pmYeah but hopefully there aren’t a lot of swallowing emergencies that take place in Heather’s home. I know we don’t do a lot of surgery at my house. But that’s my chosen profession and I love it. It’s true that there are a lot more options these days but that doesn’t mean that there are endless options.
Comment #6 by Alison WonderlandOctober 15th, 2008 at 8:14 pmYou may some day have to chose between helping a woman through childbirth and making it to one of your kids’ soccer games. There’s no right or wrong decision there but whichever you make you’ll be just a little bit sad that it didn’t go the other way.
I work full time (we wouldn’t be eating if I didn’t, and it works for us) and so I get to/have to stay on top of the latest advances in medical equipment but there are moments when I notice that I’m maybe not quite as on top of the latest advances in teething.
I’m not complaining, I don’t think any of us really are, but I don’t think any of us can help but be a little sad when we get a glimpse down the road that we didn’t chose.
Ah, the road not taken. Something I’ve been thinking a lot about lately too.
I wish I could have children young (I did) and raise them. Then go back to being young (I can’t) and do all the career stuff knowing the kid question is taken care of.
We can’t all be ageless vampires with eerily fast growing children.
Comment #7 by The WizOctober 15th, 2008 at 8:39 pmI really like this post and the discussion. The road not taken is a good way of thinking of it. Thanks, ladies.
Comment #8 by Mrs MOctober 15th, 2008 at 9:01 pmFirst of all, this post made me swallow a lot. And become really conscious of my swallowing, which is annoying. And now if I ever can’t swallow, I will probably freak out thinking that I am about to die. Thanks a lot.
Second, I think about the road not taken constantly. I have not completed college yet - had I not gotten completely burned out I would have had my bachelor’s before I turned 19, but that’s another story. I’m grateful that I have this time to raise my son because it’s giving me a chance to figure out what I really want to do. I’m also frustrated because most of the time I really want to be progressing towards that goal - but I can’t, because I’m raising my son and we have no money for school.
But at least it gives me a chance to change my mind in the next five years. Which is nice, because sometimes I feel like my career goals change on a weekly basis… yes, I did belong to the Major of the Month Club in college
Comment #9 by KrisOctober 15th, 2008 at 10:26 pmI feel the same way sometimes as I am plodding along in my PhD program and trying to raise my 1 1/2 year old son at the same time. Even though I’m still in my field, I only have a babysitter 9 hrs a week and try to smoosh my research into all my free time, which makes me feel like I am progressing like a snail compared to everyone else in my program. It’s frustrating because I feel like I’m not accomplishing much there but it’s so easy to get strung out and stressed and feel like I”m not the best mother either. And I feel like I will be hopelessly left behind if I quit the field, but I’ll be hopelessly stressed out if I don’t and try to be a de-facto stay-at-home mom at the same time. So, I definitely feel this dilemma. I think moms should get 2 days for everyone else’s one.
Comment #10 by AmandaOctober 16th, 2008 at 5:22 amI think I should also add a big “Hooray for choices!” in here, too. I am well aware of the luxury of having the choice to work or to stay home. Throughout history, women’s choices have been pretty limited, and even today, many women just don’t have the luxury of deciding to work or stay home. So please don’t think that I don’t know how lucky I am. Not that any of you have implied that, but I just wanted to make that clear.
Comment #11 by Heather O.October 16th, 2008 at 6:01 amI loved this post, Heather on a couple of different levels. First, I finished my master’s 6 weeks after giving birth to my first baby. I didn’t go back to work for 5 years and then not in the exact field I got my degree in. Practices have moved forward and I haven’t been practicing.
Second, I sometimes actually have swallowing emergencies. I wake up in the middle of the night unable to swallow and this puts my whole body in a state of panic. Because I can’t swallow properly, I start choking. It’s a weird and frightening thing. Have you ever heard of anything like this before????
Comment #12 by meemsOctober 16th, 2008 at 6:09 amFirst, I wish I had known about the swallowing cue. There would have been plenty of time for me to get home to my mother one more time, had I known what the loss of swallowing meant.
And second, it’s an open secret (one that I sometimes ask people in different professions about, with a 100% agreement) that no matter how confident you are, no matter what professional laurels you accumulate, there are times when you still feel like a fraud only pretending to be the expert, and terribly fearful that any day now people are going to wake up and discover that you’re just a little kid pretending to be grown up and pretending to know what you’re talking about. Remember that when you start comparing yourself to those in your field whom you think know oh-so-much more than you do.
Comment #13 by Ardis ParshallOctober 16th, 2008 at 6:17 amI recently wrote about my perfect life, and in it after my kids are all in school I want to go back to school and get a master’s degree (I already have my bachelors) and then work in some capacity at the same University my husband will be at (he’s getting a Phd right now, and plans to be a professor). Three of his professors from BYU have wives who also work in some capacity for BYU and in their husbands fiels - writing papers, editing, etc. I like to dream that after the bulk of my child raising is over I could go and do the same.
I keep on thinking of some of the early women in the church, specifically I’m thinking of one of Brigham Younng’s wives who went back east and trained to be a doctor (one of her sister wives took care of her kids). I know that I’m not in the same situation now, but with full time school and whatnot I do think it’s possible to have a second career in some areas after your first “mom” career is winding down.
I know that this isn’t the answer for many, nor should it be necessarily, but I guess this is how I manage to not feel like the professional world is passing me by.
Comment #14 by ThoraOctober 16th, 2008 at 6:18 amI feel like I want to say something. But I’m not sure what to say as I really hate the whole working mom vs. SAHMs debate.
It’s so popular now to tell our daughters that they can be brave and strong and do anything they want to when they grow up. And certainly there are many women professionals that I’m grateful are out there doing the jobs they do. But I want to know what ever happened to playing up the career of being a full time mother? Why is it that women HAVE to do something else besides just being a mom? I believe that getting an education is important for everyone, but why does it seem like having a family is always secondary behind have a paying career? Why do so many women feel unfulfilled in being just a mom?
Comment #15 by apple pieOctober 16th, 2008 at 6:43 amTough questions to answer.
#15 - I’m don’t know about other mothers, but the choices my child has been/is still making can suck the joy right out of being a mother.
When I had to take my 12 year old to the police station (for the second time in two months because of stealing and check forgery) and had learned that she had indeed passed stolen goods to her friends at school, I really didn’t feel all that fulfilled. Yes, I’m doing the best I can with the situation I have been given (very long in-family foster care/ adoption story), but it’s not really all that personally rewarding to see a child exercise their agency in ways that will eventually lead to more heartache and the juvenile justice system.
My child recently voiced in a discussion of her behavior that 1) she knows what she is doing is wrong, 2) she can recognize the Holy Ghost inside her telling her she is doing wrong, 3) she knows that what she is doing can be hurtful, 4) she still purposely chooses the action despite all the above, and finally, 5) she hasn’t yet, and does not plan to, apologize or ask for forgiveness from either the parties she has wronged or Heavenly Father through prayer. I’m not exactly feeling like a Helaman warrior mother.
I think that it isn’t so much degrading the role of motherhood as it is being unique individuals with talents, desires, and dreams that are not always motherhood related. I’m not even sure that having a paying career is really that big a part. The things I want to personally pursue further when my children are grown are not what I would call money makers.
**As for swallowing, I stood on my head and drank water through a straw to prove to my brother that it was throat contractions, not gravity, that forced things to the stomach. I can’t walk and swallow at the same time; I have to stop to take a drink. It annoys the heck out of my family on hikes.
Comment #16 by JuneBugOctober 16th, 2008 at 8:02 amJuneBug-
It’s true that contractions (known as peristalsis) sends things to the stomach. Gravity certainly helps, though!
And I’m sorry about what you are going through with your daughter. It sounds like you are doing what you can. Hang in there.
Apple pie–
I’m not downplaying the career of being a mother. Not at all. What I’m saying is that in life, we have to make tough choices, especially when it comes to being a parent. Or at least most women do. (And I admit it’s tougher for some than for others.) This is a post not necessarily about working vs. SAHM, but about how we deal with the consequences of our choices. And as much as I love my kids, as much as I willingly sacrifice for them, and as hard as it is to think that I can’t have any more kids, for me, it’s still hard not to be a professional anymore. What can I say, I like swallowing.
And you’re right, it’s kind of a tired story. Sorry, it was just on my mind all week.
Comment #17 by Heather O.October 16th, 2008 at 8:11 amI hereby sing the praises of part-time: school, job, community college fun class, what have you. I fervently wish every woman had the opportunity! I did graduate school part time and then (very) part time work and when I needed it, this experience served me VERY WELL.
I look at my sister and wonder what would happen to her should something happen to hubby. Not a pretty picture.
Comment #18 by ESOOctober 16th, 2008 at 9:41 amYeah, but if you had to go back, you could and you would get up to speed in no time. You have options if you ever need them. And your kids ARE way cute!
Comment #19 by wbprawOctober 16th, 2008 at 12:34 pmApple Pie-and others, I don’t think it is a tired story at all. I am at the beginning of my career as a mother and am almost 30; for me the sarifices and rewards are just beginning. And while I look forward to using the art of negotiatation, reading body language, and strategic planning with my children (all to get them to do exactly what I want of course, riiigght), there are just some skills that I LOVE and I AM GOOD AT that I simply will not be able to use raising children: such as explicating prose, preparing legislation, drafting speeches and anticipating counter arguments (ok so this skill may be useful once I get to the teenage years, but you get my drift). This make me sad. It is a part of me, a part of my identity, and is supposed to be a part of me, as we all possess God-given talents that we are to develop. Motherhood trumps interests because it should. But I don’t think that means we can’t miss the talented, successful, individually achieving us (or long to develop her) and I don’t think missing that her takes away from being fufilled as a woman or mother. That’s just me. I for one appreciate posts like this so much because it helps me realize I am not the only one who has moments of longing for the road that others took, and it also helps me appreciate the road that I did take. So thanks Heather. For a very new to the roost woman, this post did wonderful things for my soul.
Comment #20 by AlyssaOctober 16th, 2008 at 12:36 pmIt’s also interesting being on the other side of this discussion.
20 years ago we decided as a couple that I would be the one to stay at home with our children. It was what I wanted to do.
I also didn’t complete a degree.
I don’t regret staying home with my children - or even doing so through High school. I do regret not completing my degree before then. At this point the degree wouldn’t matter, at least not in the field I want to work.
At this point it doesn’t matter to prospective employers that my first programming experiences where in BASIC (The language that an apple computer USED to be programmed in) and then Dos (Before Windows there was Dos). That instead of using WYSIWYG (What You See Is What You Get) programs to do our websites when the internet was first made public I prefered to do it longhand in Notetab. And taught myself the code I needed as well as how to use the programs to design graphics that I liked to personalize my website. You want to talk about feeling old and out of date? And I’m not all that typical for my friends either (Which is why I put the information in parenthesis for those who might have gone, “What in the sam hill is she goin’ on about!”).
It’s not helping at all, so far, because self-taught just isn’t as attractive as seeing a degree and certifications on a resume.
Not to say that all is lost
It’s just a more difficult. And it will involve going back to school now. I don’t mind that. I’m looking forward to it. But it will be more difficult than when I was younger.
Comment #21 by MommomOctober 16th, 2008 at 1:13 pmI’m terrified of what will happen to me if my husband kicks the bucket. I have no degree and I have no marketable skills. I’d be screwed.
Comment #22 by KrisOctober 16th, 2008 at 4:26 pmI really appreciated this quote that is in Oct’s VT message:
Elder M. Russell Ballard of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles: “The premortal and mortal natures of men and women were specified by God Himself. … [Sometimes women] ask: ‘Is a woman’s value dependent exclusively upon her role as a wife and mother?’ The answer is simple and obvious: No. … Every righteous man and woman has a significant role to play in the onward march of the kingdom of God. …”
Honestly, when I was reading it, I was surprised. It was a great reminder for me that there is more for me to do in addition to being a wife and mother. I have a masters degree and had a terrific career before I had kids, but I’ve been so focused on toddlers and babies lately, I haven’t worked much on anything else. I guess there’s a time and season for everything, right?
Comment #23 by janeOctober 16th, 2008 at 8:06 pmThere is absolutely a time and season for everything.
And even when you are a mom doesn’t mean you need to stop learning about other things.
Lastly - look to callings and other volunteer work to learn and improve marketable skills.
And please, if you can (and haven’t already), find a way to work in getting your degree. Even if it’s class by class over 20 years. By the time your children are moving out you’ll be done - or close to it and ready to move back out into the world.
Comment #24 by MommomOctober 17th, 2008 at 6:39 amWhat I wouldn’t give to have to make the decision between children and work! And to have someone to make that decision with. And here are mothers somewhat envying those who have careers!
Here is a comment from the OTHER other side of the spectrum. Let me preface my comment with this: I really like the comments already made partly because it makes me feel like I can have a fulfulling life being the best engineer I can be and by serving in the comunity and my church calling… because you guys see it as being fulfilling!
The hardest part of being old and single is when Church leaders tell woman that the ultimate fulfillment of the Fathers plan is in being a mother and serving in the church… oh… but the rest of u who don’t have that oportunity… hope u can be fulfulled with whatever ur doing. OK, so I know they don’t mean it that way (case in point: the quote mentioned in comment 23), but most days thats how it feels. Just know that I envy all of u… I envy the purpose and meaning I PROJECT you feel in your lives. I envy the love and companionship I PROJECT you feel every day. I envy u the oportunities you have to increase your cooking/cleaning/crafting/parenting/economizing skills (strange but true!). I envy you. Yes, u…. and u…. I guess the grass always looks greener on the other side. But really… ur side is definitely greener!
Comment #25 by Smart HelmOctober 17th, 2008 at 10:12 am[…] Last week I was reading one of my favorite group Mormon woman blogs, and halfway through the post I felt disturbed, betrayed, cheated. I’ve had a mild blog crush on Heather O. for a while now, and I just couldn’t believe she was using words like “conferences,” “continuing education,” “license,” “our patients,” and “graduate school.” […]
Pingback #26 by Thoroughly Unworthy Emotions | What About MomOctober 20th, 2008 at 8:15 amThanks Heather. I appreciated the discussion as well. I haven’t yet come to the fork in the road, but because I know I will and will want to be able to get off and be a SAHM for a while and still keep my hand in professional activities, I am trying to prepare for it now. But its not easy. It isn’t easy to be in law school and listen to people talk about interviewing with big firms and starting 6-figure salaries or working as District Attorneys and knowing that I will have to pass those roads by as I watch my classmates veer off. So much of what I am trained to do and excel out with be useful in a very structured and competitive environment where any time out of the loop is career suicide.
I agree with the “seasons” view of a woman’s life and hope it will all work out of the best…eventually. Let’s hope that public interest, non-profit work will be more forgiving and flexible…
Comment #27 by BrittanyOctober 20th, 2008 at 10:20 am