By Melissa Mc
I’m a long way from being Becky Bloomwood, but when life gets in a rut…I buy new laundry detergent.
When I walk down the laundry aisle, my eyes gloss over imagining how awesome my clothes will look once I try one (or more) of the HUNDREDS of products offered. Have you thought about how many bottles and boxes clog the shelves of supermarkets promising gleaming whites, spotless shirts, brilliant colors, germ free bliss? For me, it’s one step short of nirvana. Do you know that Tide alone has 9 different types of detergent (yes, I stood in the aisle and counted – but that’s only the liquid – it doesn’t include powder or their HE versions). Thank you Proctor and Gamble, for giving me all those choices! Let’s see, should I try Tide Coldwater? Color Protectant? With a touch of Downy? Pure Essentials? With Dawn Stain Scrubbers (I thought Dawn was for dishes)? Or least I forget Tide Original or Tide FREE. Do you think they actually change the recipe of said product or do they just change the label for suckers like me who think one bottle is going to transform their life?
Ohhh…and what about laundry additives? Colorox safe bleach? Washing soda? Borax? Zout? Shout? Bluing agent? Bleach? Or that stuff from the loud guy on TV? I’m sure his magic elixir will “kick my laundry up a notch” because when someone’s yelling really loud it must be good! I’m so sucked into this marketing vortex, my DH thinks I need professional help. I NEED that perfect load of laundry. I want my kid’s clothes to be admired and gleaming and white and smelly fresh! Initially, I was a non-fragrant, dye free detergent chick, until my 8 yr old told me how her clothes didn’t smell very good (how dare she question the mistress of laundry!). Currently, I use no fewer than 2-3 types of detergent, depending on my mood. I also caved to the Tide Coldwater scheme, since I’m using more cold water to wash clothes in an attempt to be environmentally-friendly. I buy huge bags of baking soda from Sam’s, because as it says on the bag, “add 1 c. with liquid laundry detergent for cleaner, fresher clothes.” Yeah, I’m sold. Now that I use cold water, I worry about GERMS. Why haven’t they made a sanitizing detergent? So, to offset my germ-o-mania, I’ve added Lysol 4 in 1, to kill germs in my towel and sheet loads (don’t remind me about my earlier environmentally-friendly claim). Finally, they say that vinegar added to the rinse cycle is the answer. A tag line on a website says, “It’s a safe and inexpensive way to boost the power of your detergent and add a little more muscle to your stain remover. With vinegar in the mix, your clothes have never looked better.” Who can pass up a statement like that?
So, there you have it – I’ve come CLEAN – I’ve admitted to my laundry obsession. Do you want my version of the perfect load of laundry? Mix one part detergent and one part baking soda/germ killer – followed by vinegar rinse, then dry as usual. I just ordered dryerballs, to eliminate the use of dryer sheets – the jury is still out. They claim to eliminate static, cut drying time and lint. I haven’t noticed a change in any of the aforementioned. However, I haven’t given them up, yet. I’m not sure how my loads compare to my less obsessive compulsive friends. I’m sure if you stacked my clean clothes against a load done in an, on-sale, no-name brand detergent, without the use of an additive, they wouldn’t look much different. Unless, of course, you consulted Becky Bloomwood.
(No actresses, real or imaginary, were harmed in the writing of this post.)




I hate walking down the laundry aisle…the mix of smells gives me a headache. But I love fresh smelling clothes.
Laundry detergent is so expensive. After my bottle of Kirkland brand detergent is finished I am going to start making my own! It costs only pennies a load and reportedly works great.
Comment #1 by AubreyFebruary 25th, 2009 at 8:50 pmI didn’t think laundry detergent mattered all that much, and usually went with cheap. But then I just got a Costco sized thing of Gain (with the Costco coupon) and I am LOVING the smell of my clothes. Sleeping with such aromatic sheets is heaven. I’m totally excited to get all my clothes smelling so awesome.
And vinegar may work well, but it sure is stinky.
Aubrey, do you have a recipe for making your detergent? Please share!
Comment #2 by Heather O.February 25th, 2009 at 9:14 pmIt’s like me and office supplies. I don’t work in an office, heaven help me I’ll never have to work in an office, but I get the HUGEST rush from visiting a Staples or Office Depot!
And I never buy the same brand of shampoo or body wash twice in a row. EVER. Gotta keep it fresh, right?
Comment #3 by SallyGirlFebruary 25th, 2009 at 9:17 pmS’mee, a frequent commenter and friend (Knot in the String) recently posted this video tutorial on making your own laundry detergent. She says it’s awseom and CHEAP to make! I haven’t tried it yet, but it looks intrigueing, and I plan on it…
http://knotinthestring.blogspot.com/2009/02/liquid-gel-laundry-soap-tutorial_16.html
Comment #4 by Tracy MFebruary 25th, 2009 at 9:21 pmWho is Becky Bloomwood? Must google…..
I like Liquid Tide. (high efficiency. Seriously, my washer/dryer ROCKS. I use like a tablespoon of detergent.) All else fails. And by “all else” I mean the Costco brand (ick, which bummed me out because usually I like Kirkland) and All. Those are the only ones I’ve tried. Although now maybe I must try Gain.
But one purchase of the Big Tide lasts me forever because I love my machines!!! (Came with the house. BIG selling point.)
Comment #5 by The WizFebruary 25th, 2009 at 9:40 pmYeah, my HE Frontloaders came with the house, too- BIG selling point. (Do I have the only husband who calls a front-clasp bra a frontloader?)
Comment #6 by Tracy MFebruary 25th, 2009 at 9:43 pmAs I was reading, I was just afraid you were going to have some kind of chemical reaction and your washing machine was going to blow up.
But, I pretty much suck at laundry, and I don’t think any product will save me, unless they make one that’s kind of like a robotic detergent that will move your clothes to the dryer and then fold them. That. would. be. awesome.
Comment #7 by Steph @ Diapers and DivinityFebruary 25th, 2009 at 9:46 pmCan’t. Stop. Laughing…..
Comment #8 by Heather O.February 25th, 2009 at 9:50 pmOh, to have a frontloader — bra, washing machine, or otherwise!
Comment #9 by Melissa McFebruary 25th, 2009 at 9:54 pmCan’t afford Tide
Don’t like Gain
I love Era, I pour it directly on stains now if needed.
What kills the germs in clothing more than the washing machine is the dryer. I bake clothing if needed on my antibacterial (heats for 2 plus hours) button on my dryer. Nothing is alive after that LOL
Comment #10 by SarahFebruary 25th, 2009 at 10:04 pmAny of you laundry wizards have recommendations of products for hand washing laundry? Not for washing frothy little bits of nylon and lace, but for washing everything that might be in the family wash? (May you never know by experience, but there are still people — me — who live in apartments too small for washing machines, who draw the line at carting around dirty laundry by bus, and who spend long hours up to our elbows in suds at the kitchen sink. Really. You think chapped hands are bad? Try chapped elbows.)
Comment #11 by Ardis ParshallFebruary 25th, 2009 at 10:09 pmI’m going to promptly look into this, Ardis. I’m also wishing I had a million $$ so I could send you a tiny, apartment-sized stackable set.
Comment #12 by Tracy MFebruary 25th, 2009 at 10:39 pmTracy, thanks for the hat tip!
The laundry soap I make works well for front loaders and also HE machines, low suds if any (once it’s in the machine), seems to be fine for a very allergic and persnickety daughter of mine who has very sensitive skin, no scents added (you can if you want in the form of essential oils, 5-10 drops), no dyes. It does have a scent by way of ingredients, however in our experience it rinses out cleanly (very well) and just leaves the clothes clean and fresh.
At approx. 320 large full loads, a $5.00 investment and about an hour total in production, it has been well worth the hassle of making it.
Hope that helps.
the link again:
http://knotinthestring.blogspot.com/2009/02/liquid-gel-laundry-soap-tutorial_16.html
Comment #13 by s'meeFebruary 25th, 2009 at 11:07 pmArdis, in a few weeks check back at my blog as I will have a tutorial on making your own “hand wash washing machine”. CHEAP, easy (seriously, you could have a five year old “work” it), and it also works. I am demo-ing it for anyone who wants a camp washer or for their self reliance storage. If you want me to send you a heads up when the tute comes out send me you e-mail and I will!
pilokween@msn.com
Comment #14 by s'meeFebruary 25th, 2009 at 11:19 pmI’ll watch for it, s’mee. Some apartments are too small, or lack plumbing, even for stackables!
Comment #15 by Ardis ParshallFebruary 25th, 2009 at 11:42 pmThanks for the tute s’mee. I had seen this a number of places around but never a picture step by step. My only q is does it fade darks? And does it get out baby stains?
I have also seen on the web a recipe for dry powder with soap, oxi-clean and something else–borax maybe? YOu can google it if you want to find it.
I so plan on making this.
Comment #16 by AubreyFebruary 26th, 2009 at 6:25 ams’mee I’m ready for a personal laundry soap making class!!
Comment #17 by Melissa McFebruary 26th, 2009 at 6:36 amOh, and i just want to say the Confessions of a Shopaholic is a very fun movie. I highly reccomend it. The book is also very very fun to read. The movie is a bit different from the book of course, but I still loved it.
Comment #18 by AubreyFebruary 26th, 2009 at 7:46 amI’d LOVE to know how to make a camp washer. Seriously, smee, let us know!
Comment #19 by Heather O.February 26th, 2009 at 8:05 amVinegar smells bad going in, but you can’t smell it at all on your laundry coming out. I use it all the time; it works wonders when you have a bed-wetter or a baby diaper leaking onto pajamas and sheets (takes the urine smell right out).
I went to the Elem school science fair last night. One of the girls’ experiments was comparing her mom’s homemade detergent with Tide. The homemade one. It’s very similar to S’mee’s, but uses 1/3 bar Fels Naptha, 1/2 c. washing soda, 1/2 c. Borax, 6 cups water. Use 1/2 c. per load.
I have kids with sensitive skin. So the first 2 years of life we use Dreft and then I switch to All Free and Clear. I personally don’t like strong-smelling laundry so whenever we get hand-me-downs I always have to wash them first (even if they were just barely washed) just to try to tone down the detergent/fabric softener smells.
Comment #20 by JESFebruary 26th, 2009 at 9:07 amSometimes I wish they made perfume that smells like the Gain that comes in the purple plastic bottle.
Comment #21 by Susan MFebruary 26th, 2009 at 9:25 amOOoooooh I have a bed wetter too. Vinegar in the rinse? Have to remember that.
I don’t like the heavy detergent smells and my skin is allergic to the dryer sheets. I get the cheapest unscented detergent I can find. My washer doesn’t have a way to switch over to cold water unless it’s the gentle cycle so my carbon footprint is huge. Oh well, utility employees need to work too.
Comment #22 by mormonhermitmomFebruary 26th, 2009 at 9:28 amSmee…I’m going to try this! I have a couple of questions (sorry to threadjack Michelle Mc!)
1. How well does this homemade soap do with towels? ( I find I have to use clorox bleach with my Tide so the towels don’t smell musty)
2. How long can you keep it in the 5 gallon bucket? (i’m thinking this would be good and cheap for long-term storage!)
Thanks!
Comment #23 by LizFebruary 26th, 2009 at 9:37 amLiz
Mel, how come I have to read your fabulous new blog to know that you use baking soda in your laundry?!!! I feel like I don’t even know who you are anymore.
Happy blogging. You’re doing great!
Comment #24 by Franchelle, Melissa's neighborFebruary 26th, 2009 at 9:57 amVery fun. Once the monkeys developed the habit of rolling in mud and chocolate while skinning their knees, I switched to Tide with bleach. I am going to try the homemade stuff. Tide is bankrupting us.
Comment #25 by JamiFebruary 26th, 2009 at 10:00 amI’m a smeller. I go for the smell. I used to be a strict Tide with bleach liquid chick, but then we got all poor and all. I tried the Kirkland “green” liquid, and it was a huge disappointment. I didn’t feel like it got out any stains (I have 6 and 3 year old boys, and an 8 month old girl — we have Stains). So I begrudgingly went back to Tide with color safe bleach. Then, the last time, in a burst of frugality, I bought the BIG-A box of Kirkland powder with bleach and I LOVE it! It smells nice, and gets rid of every stain I’ve thrown at it. I also use Shout on a very regular basis. I wish Costco would learn that Spray’n'Wash is far inferior and make the switch. Also, because I like the smellies — I’m totally hooked on my Downy ball filled with (I think it’s) something cashmere — the bottle is peach. Then, because DH likes dryer sheets, I put those in too. Coordinating smells, of course.
Wow… who knew I’d have so much to say about laundry. Although I guess since I do it every day, I’m bound to have an opinion.
Comment #26 by teresaFebruary 26th, 2009 at 10:23 amFor stains, ZOUT in the squeezie bottle even gets out stains that have been through the dryer. NO JOKE.
Comment #27 by Tracy MFebruary 26th, 2009 at 10:39 amI’ve heard about Zout — but never tried it — just admired it on the shelf.
I should have included this…but according to Consumer Reports — Tide with Bleach HE — is supposed to be the winner of their detergent testing.
Comment #28 by Melissa McFebruary 26th, 2009 at 11:00 am#22 - I just pour the vinegar into the bleach slot in my washer as I’m adding the detergent. So I don’t worry about whether it’s during the rinse cycle or whatever.
Comment #29 by JESFebruary 26th, 2009 at 11:33 amI make my own detergent, and I love it. I use 1 bar of soap, grated, 1 cup washing soda, and 1/2 cup borax, and enough hot water to fill a 5 gallon bucket. I can make a batch in about 20 minutes for about $2, and it lasts for months. (Of course, I’m single, so if you have kids, it’ll go a bit faster.)
Ardis, if you want a good washer that doesn’t require plumbing, you could try the Wonderwash. I used it before I moved into an apartment with a washer. http://www.laundry-alternative.com/products/Wonderwash.html
Comment #30 by Keri BrooksFebruary 26th, 2009 at 12:39 pmKeri — when you say 1 bar of soap — do you mean any soap, like Ivory or Safeguard? Or are there special bar soaps needed to make detergent?? I keep Borax and washing soda stocked on my shelf.
Comment #31 by Melissa McFebruary 26th, 2009 at 12:44 pmAny soap will work. I’ve used glycerin soap, Ivory soap, Irish Spring (that one smells like regular laundry detergent), etc. Often I’ll save hotel soaps and use a bunch of them to make a batch.
Comment #32 by Keri BrooksFebruary 26th, 2009 at 12:50 pmI pour the vinegar into the softener hole in my washer then it comes out during the rinse. It’d never get in there any other way!
Comment #33 by JamiFebruary 26th, 2009 at 12:57 pmWhat’s the difference between washing soda and baking soda?
Comment #34 by Tracy MFebruary 26th, 2009 at 1:18 pmWashing soda is Na2CO3 and baking soda is NaHCO3, so the difference is two Na’s and one H.
Comment #35 by ResearcherFebruary 26th, 2009 at 1:25 pmWhoops! I meant one Na!
Comment #36 by ResearcherFebruary 26th, 2009 at 1:25 pmJami: That’s how I add my vinegar…the useful softener dispenser.
Thanks researcher for the chemical equation!! You don’t want to COOK with your washing soda!
This is helpful:
http://www.boston.com/news/science/articles/2006/12/11/whats_the_difference_between_washing_soda_and_baking_soda/
Comment #37 by Melissa McFebruary 26th, 2009 at 1:29 pmWAshing soda is harsher and more alkaline than baking and will clean really well. Google it–here is one helpful link: http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-washing-soda.htm
Comment #38 by AubreyFebruary 26th, 2009 at 1:29 pmWashing soda is sodium carbonate (Na2CO3). It’s slightly caustic and can’t be eaten. Baking soda is sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3) and is milder and edible. They’re both white powders. I’ve made laundry detergent with both, and washing soda works better. Baking soda will still get the clothes clean, but the detergent doesn’t gel up as nicely when making it.
Comment #39 by Keri BrooksFebruary 26th, 2009 at 1:30 pmWiz,
Becky (Rebecca) Bloomwood is the title character in “Confessions of a Shopaholic” (didn’t see anyone answer your question, so hopefully I didn’t miss it when I just scanned the comments). Cute book (just go in with low expectations) and I can’t wait to see the movie. I’m a bit partial because I share her name.
And I heart frontloaders, too. But I really don’t spend much time on laundry which is why I still like doing it. If I spent any more time I think I’d hate it.
Comment #40 by StarababaFebruary 26th, 2009 at 1:31 pmA second the vinegar comments. It really works well when you have to wash a blanket that the cat has loved, and/or peed on.
It washes the scent out, which is really important b/c cats tend to go again and again in the same place IF they can smell themselves. I had to do this once, and the vinegar smell didn’t hang around at all.
Comment #41 by LisaCFebruary 26th, 2009 at 3:20 pmHi, frequent reader, rare commenter here. I work in the clothing and textile industry and thought I would pass on this little tidbit. When clothing manufacturers are evaluating products for their lines they test wash them in the 3 most popular brands of detergent. The overall most popular brand is Tide, followed by Cheer, and unfortunately the third brand escapes me at the moment. So when clothing is carried in stores it is with the assumption that it will last the longest and stay looking the best when washed with the top detergents.
Comment #42 by KirstenFebruary 26th, 2009 at 4:38 pmI love the liquid Tide HE original and then I pair it with good smelling liquid fabric softeners. And I always have several choices available in case I don’t feel like using one, I can use one of my other three or four choices. That said, Gain(think it was gain) has an Apple Mango Tango flavor detergent and fabric softener that I LOVE. But, I have yet to find it in HE, since I got my new washer and dryer. Oh well.
Comment #43 by BFebruary 26th, 2009 at 5:05 pmk, I am way too lazy to read the comments, but I just had to put a shout out there for my favorite laundry soup - Carlie’s Soup. It is cheap, no smelly perfumes, it doesn’t leave a residue, and it cleans well. You can buy it online.
Comment #44 by aprilFebruary 26th, 2009 at 5:48 pmOk…now I am hooked ladies. This is nutty. So, has anyone used Soap Nuts? They are supposed to be “green” and re-usable. You can google them. I also have a front loader, but not really loving it. We get a lof of risidual water in the gap between the barrel and the door. How do you get rid of that water? I leave the door open all the time, but it never evaporates. In the summer it can get musty smelling. Any advice is welcomed.
Oh, I will try the Vinegar. I heard about home made laundry soap years ago and never tried it and now I am intrigued, especially since a decent bottle of detergent is like $8-$10 bucks! That is cutting into my Target shoe budget.
Comment #45 by KatieFebruary 26th, 2009 at 6:05 pmHuh. I do not have that water problem. But then, I live in the desert. I wonder if you should have someone look at it. (just don’t let him/her give you parenting advice.
)
Comment #46 by The WizFebruary 26th, 2009 at 6:51 pmUmm… I got nothin. I think you might be certifiable.
Comment #47 by wbprawFebruary 26th, 2009 at 7:44 pmMy sister LOVES dryerballs! Great advice and entertainment throughout this post.
Comment #48 by Michelle AMFebruary 26th, 2009 at 11:53 pm#11-
Ardis, here’s something we used for your situation. Thank you Amish people!
http://www.lehmans.com/shopping/product/detailmain.jsp?itemID=1600&itemType=PRODUCT&RS=1&keyword=pressure+washer
We used this to wash cloth diapers. It worked ok, but as you can imagine the whole process was pretty messy. For normal laundry when your other option is the kitchen sink, I think it should be a lot more tolerable. Especially if you have a bathtub to dump the water into, instead of having to precision-aim it into the toilet/sink/closet shower like we did….
I would recommend stuffing the clothes into a mesh washing bag when using this thing. Makes it possible to grab everything out quickly so you can squeeze the water out before/during/after rinsing- otherwise it’s not that much easier than the sink.
****
The reason we did this with cloth diapers was that, while we do have a laundromat in the complex, all them wonderful detergent extras tend to leave a thin coating of waxy perfumey stuff on the inside of washers and driers. This isn’t generally a problem unless your cloth items’ goal in life is to soak up water as fast as possible, in which case you want that cotton to be bare-bones nekked. Also, after a couple of public laundry washes that gum on the diapers would start to hold onto urine solutes and the diapers would start reeking like ammonia the minute she peed and got the gunk wet.
Then we found out that if you run a load of whites in a public washer on hot with some Oxy-Clean, THEN run the diapers, problem solved. Haven’t done them by hand since.
We use Charlie’s Soap for this too- it’s nothing but detergent, so you use a ridiculously small amount.
Comment #49 by melliferaFebruary 27th, 2009 at 7:01 amOk, so I’ve got a question for all you laundry fiends out there. If you’ve got a HE washer, do you have to use HE detergent? The last bottle of regular detergent (left over from when we moved, so we went ahead and used it up) seemed to leave a lot of soap left over from one load to the next. Then I got the Tide HE and loved it. So I told DH to buy it the next time we needed detergent and he was at the store, but he said it cost $18 for a bottle, so he got a bottle of cheapo normal detergent (scented…blegh), instead. So now I have to use up this bottle of detergent.
I’d like to try making my own detergent, but I’ve got an infant who gets into EVERYTHING on the floor and there is nowhere else that I could store a 5-gallon bucket that’s anywhere near my laundry (I guess I could put it in the garage…would a very hot AZ summer garage do anything bad to the soap?).
Comment #50 by kaduseyFebruary 27th, 2009 at 7:46 amThanks for the links to the handwashers, you experts. I’d never heard of such a thing. I might even be able to find a corner in this closet-sized apartment to stash it — or at least a spot on the ceiling where I could hang it from a hook!
Comment #51 by Ardis ParshallFebruary 27th, 2009 at 8:06 am#50, It took a long time before they had All free and clear in an HE formula. I used both Dreft and All regular with no problem in my front loader. The trick is that you have to use less, like half as much, so you don’t get all the suds. My clothes still got completely clean. The HE is formulated differently to produce less bubbles than regular detergent.
Comment #52 by JESFebruary 27th, 2009 at 11:57 amHello, Neat post. There is a problem along with your web site in internet explorer, could check this? IE still is the marketplace leader and a good element of people will leave out your wonderful writing due to this problem.
Comment #53 by laundryNovember 3rd, 2011 at 9:58 amPretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your blog and in accession capital to say that I acquire in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your augment and even I fulfillment you get admission to persistently quickly.
Comment #54 by ariel detergentDecember 12th, 2012 at 6:52 pm