By Heather O.
Ho. Lee. Cow.I’m trying to wrap my mind around this, and I just can’t. Here are my questions:
1) What the heck “lies in the shadow of the statue?” What was the language Richard responded with? Spanish? Latin? Curse my monolingualism. (Actually, I do know quite a bit of German, but that hasn’t come in handy with this show. DH’s Korean has, though. Who woulda thunk?)
2) Who is the guy who wants to kill Jacob? Have we seen him before and I’ve just forgotten? What’s the loophole? What’s the deal altogether?
3) If John Locke is really dead, then we know that the other people who keep appearing on the island as the walking undead or whatever are really, um, what?
4) Is the smoke monster behind all this?
And I gotta say, for people who had to hijack a sub and beat the crap out of a few folks, Juliet and Sawyer sure did change their minds in a jiffy. Kate, also, risked her life to make sure that Jack didn’t detonate the bomb, and yet with a nod from “Blondie” and her guy Sawyer, she’s all set to let Jack blow them all to smithereens. Awfully convenient.
And how is blowing up the island going to get Kate back? Are they going to have some “Made in Heaven” moment where they pass each other on the street, and just KNOW? Come to think of it, Jacob sort of does resemble that weird smoking God character in that movie, and Jacob is sort of supposed to BE God, right? So maybe the writers are abandoning the Narnia thread and just going with cheesy 80 movie themes now.
And if Jacob is supposed to be God, is Ben supposed to be Job? I mean, he kind of gets to yell at God like Job did, and Jacob sort of gives him a back handed answer. Is this the writer’s way of saying that really, Job deserved something better than a “Where were you when I created the world” in answer to his boils erupting all over his face?
And who is coming? I’m trying to remember what happens in the chronology of the island to think of what or who Jacob is talking about–everybody that we know about is already there, right? Dharma, Rosseau, Widmore, everybody. Are there even more “other others?”
Okay, question of the day: Was the light really the bomb going off, or another flash? And given how this show works, we’re probably going to have to wait for that answer for another year.
I want arms like Kate. And Sayid—(sigh). I just like looking at the guy. Hope he didn’t die.
Anyway, I gotta say that I’m really looking forward to next year, although I find it irritating that we have to wait such a long time to get back into this. Surely I will have forgotten almost everything by next January.




1) latin for “He who will save us all”
2 and 3 and 4) We have never seen the man in black. I like to think he is behind the smoke monster, walking christian, and any other apparition on the island trying to do “bad stuff”
Do you ever read Jeff Jensen’s articles on ew.com?
He does awesome analysis and recaps of each episode.
Comment #1 by daveMay 15th, 2009 at 1:08 pmI believe the “what lies under the statue” answer is latin and means “He who will protect us all.”
So I think the people that are coming are the others from the past. Jacob visited each one of them and physically touched them. Maybe he knew they had to come to save the island?
I can’t believe we have to wait eight months.
Comment #2 by kateastropheMay 15th, 2009 at 1:16 pmNINE months. Oui. Even worse.
Comment #3 by kateastropheMay 15th, 2009 at 1:17 pm1. Already answered! I heard it was more of a combination of the two: protect/save.
Comment #4 by KimMay 15th, 2009 at 1:47 pm2. Did we all notice how the bad guy was wearing black and Jacob was wearing white? Another black vs white, good vs evil. I’m definitely sure we haven’t seen him before, I most definitely think he’s behind the monster (because it’s just evil) and I think the loophole is that he can only appear as people who come to the island already dead- Christian and now Locke. I also think he was the one using the cabin, acting as Christian, pretending to speak for Jacob, sort of an antichrist is you will.
Here’s my far fetched theory about the “who” that Jacob says is coming: Too easy to say it’s the people outside who just saw Locke’s dead body. I think the bright light was a flash and everyone from the 70’s is going to show up in the time they’re supposed to be in. Sun needs to be with Jin. And I don’t like the idea that Claire would never have met Charlie, Desmond would never have ended up back with Penny (and had they’re son Charlie). Sawyer and Juliet, Jack and Kate. There’s definitely a reason they all met, I don’t know what it is, but I don’t want to think that the bomb is going to wipe everything away and they’ll land in LAX.
Ugh! What an episode! Here are my theories.
Jacob and Dark shirt guy. I think it is like the Jacob/Esau story…mixed with Job. I don’t think Jacob is God, but I do think there is some thing where he does the bidding for God or whatever rules everything there in Losty world. I do think dark shirt guy was posing as Christian and/or other dead people. I think the loophole was that someone else had to kill him, maybe even Ben who may be the “true leader.” I also think that Richard may be shown as someone who was on the “ship” from the first scene. Maybe he has been stuck there since then.
Poor Juliet. I hope she gets a better ending. Poor Sawyer. I felt the actor who plays him did a really good job. I actually got a little teary myself. (I know, big nerd). Jack and Kate, I could care less about.
I was watching The View the other day and the actor that plays Hurley was on it and he said something that he hopes it doesn’t “reset” or be a dream, which makes me think it is not. I am glad they are ending it. I hate it when shows go on too long. But, I also hate it when they take forever to come back on!
I loved seeing Rose and Bernard.
Comment #5 by KatieMay 15th, 2009 at 2:29 pmI actually think its more like Jacob and Not-Jacob are two angels– One likes humans the other doesn’t. I think the Not-Jacob is Smokey. He takes the forms of dead people to influence other people to do what he needs them to do.
The loop hole was that Not-Jacob couldn’t kill Jacob, but someone else could. It had to be the leader of the Others– which was Ben since Locke is dead. (which makes me wonder if Locke really had to die, or was smokey just blowing, well, smoke…)
Remember that dream that Walt had, when Locke went to visit him? Walt said that he had been having dreams about Locke, being back on the island and bad people were chasing him and he was wearing a suit. When has he ever been in a suit on the island… except for now? Also, I think it was Claire that had that dream about Locke, and he had 1 black eye and 1 white eye… (Did you notice the logo change at the end?)
What if Jacob can do the same as Not-Jacob and takes the form of the Real Locke? This would explain Claires dream, the book “Good twin/Bad twin” that was published in real life (and promoted on the TV show), and Walts dream. I think there is going to be a “war in heaven” type of event. (cheesy, but plausible)
I think Richard probably was on the Black Rock and Jacob liked him and made him an immortal to stick around and do his “bidding.”
On one of the episodes Daniel Faraday talked about how everyone had to have a constant. For a while, people were theorizing that the constant was Desmond. However, I think that everyone’s constant is Jacob. He was there for everyone, at pivotal moments in their lives.
The thing that I didn’t get was Hurley. Hurley was the only one that Jacob communicated with, using their name. He said stuff to the other people… but Hurley was the only one where he actually talked WITH him. Like they knew each other. Why? What in the crap did that mean?
Comment #6 by MotherboardMay 15th, 2009 at 6:17 pmI always like your episode recaps, Heather, because they’re completely based on emotion and reaction-response, as opposed to many other bloggers who immediately try to make everything fit in to their pet theory.
Oh, yes, Kate’s arms are covet-worthy. Sayid? I can understand the appeal, but I’m not feeling it.
Something about the episode has been bugging me, and when someone commented on kulturblog, I think, that there was something vaguely Mormon about it, I realized what it was. The opening scene with Jacob and his nemesis made me think of the D&C section that talks about how to use the shaking hands (physical touch) test to tell if an angel is good or bad.
Touch is clearly very important to Jacob…he touched every character he visited, and it was so deliberate. But his nemesis seems unable to touch anyone. (Perhaps anything? Maybe that was why he didn’t want any of Jacob’s red snapper. Seemed like they were sharing an inside joke about the fish.) Anyway, maybe one of the rules is that evil-guy can’t touch anyone. When Locke fell in the well, remember how Jack’s dad didn’t help him? That’s when this idea started swimming around in my head. Something’s definitely up with that.
Does anyone remember any of the undead ever touching any of the characters? Or being touched?
Comment #7 by AhnaMay 15th, 2009 at 9:03 pmI also think that smokey is the dark guy or not-jacob. As for a Mormon reference, I see a bit of it. I like your good angel/bad spirit idea. I also think there is some “war in heaven” sort of thing going on, especially where at the end there was a strong emphasis on free will and choice. Oh and progress. I have seen some people referring to the fish reference as biblical with even Ben saying he is a pisces, that was a good line BTW.
Comment #8 by KatieMay 16th, 2009 at 5:58 amOoh, so Richard’s like one of the Lostian Three Nephites!
See, this show really IS Mormon!
Comment #9 by AngelaMay 16th, 2009 at 6:13 amactually if you even take it to Cain and Abel…Jesus, Satan… one good one bad.
But my theory is Jacob didn’t die. And, here’s why, because black shirt guy was so focused on killing Jacob he forgot what was going on in the different time zone.
Juliet sacrifices herself to hit the reset button…in the past… I know the whole day and night thing doesn’t match up, but that’s all I got. And if that isn’t the case then the bomb does go off, blowing off the top of the statue, resetting everything which makes the cycle start all over again.
Gosh, now I am confusing myself. Oh, and next season is the last.
Who was the girl that carried Locke and how do they fit in? Huh? HUH? I just started freaking out after the show was over and i have waited three days for this… thanks Heather for posting. I love these~!
Comment #10 by SunshineMay 16th, 2009 at 7:52 amThis episode blew my mind. The religious similarities are fascinating, and I don’t doubt they are intentional (whatever the right answers are).
I’m excited for the last season. We’ll finally find out WHY. WHY WHY WHY!
Comment #11 by HilaryMay 16th, 2009 at 9:27 amOH, and this is pretty cool:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1HAEN96nJ4c&annotation_id=annotation_364436&feature=iv
Comment #12 by HilaryMay 16th, 2009 at 10:27 amI was thinking of Ben as Judas - as in…willing to kill the creator out of spite or jealousy or a few gold coins…whatever it takes.
Comment #13 by KamiMay 16th, 2009 at 2:55 pmI have to echo dave’s post above - ew.com Jeff Jensen - great recaps, great explanations. He has a great wealth of remembering past episodes. Since reading them I haven’t been as confused as I would before. Go read the LOST recaps online at EW.COM!
Comment #14 by QueenScarlettMay 16th, 2009 at 3:46 pmI went to the ew.com site as well and it did have good insights. I am liking he theory that Jacob built in some loopholes too. There was a mention that with each past visit, other then Juliet, Jacob touched the people and gave them something. Also, exclude Sayid, so he may die after all, but Jacob did visit him, just didn’t give him anything. So, when he says, “They’re coming” at the end, he is referring to Jack, Kate, Sawyer, Hurley, Jin and Sun. Somehow they will be able to make things right. So, we will see. But, it has been fun speculating.
Comment #15 by KatieMay 17th, 2009 at 10:55 amAnyone else remember the crazy dude in the asylum who told Hurley the numbers way back long time ago? I’m pretty sure it is the same guy who made Dr Chang turn the drill on again since he’d been working on the project for 6 years. You know, the straggly dude with the glasses….
Comment #16 by AmyMay 17th, 2009 at 9:57 pmOk, just kidding….I just found this site. http://lost.wikia.com/wiki/The_Incident
And thanks to the wealth of LOST info, I remembered that the dharma dude with scraggly hair and glasses wasn’t in the insane asylum—that was some other dude named Leonard who directed Hurley to visit the one-legged woman on the ranch in the middle of nowhere in Australia so many moons ago.
Seriously though, check out this site. It is a goldmine of keeping LOST facts straight!
Comment #17 by AmyMay 17th, 2009 at 10:18 pmOK! I hated and loved the finale.
I definitely think that the white light at the end is the explosion, which leaves the real question….did all the events reset back to the plane landing in LAX, OR will they be back on the island!! Did you see the previews for next season?? Just an eye opening…just how it started (with Jack opening his eyes on the island)! Very cool.
BUT was anyone else totally disappointed with the anti-climatic death of Jacob?? Ben lifts up a knife and with two slow-motion stabs, THE Jacob is dead. Lame.
I hope LOST doesn’t pull an “Independence Day 2″ with John Locke pulling off a mask and turning into Charles Witmore. Ahhhhh…too bad we have to wait until next YEAR!
Comment #18 by EmmeMay 18th, 2009 at 12:18 amOk, here is what my hubby and i think:
Everyone in the 70s is going to wake up naked in the jungle, in a deja vu of Desmond after the Swan station blew up last time they went through this whole “do we destroy the swan station or not”
The black shirt guy can only take the shape of someone who has been dead before their body came to the island—therefore all of the appearances of Christian have been the black shirt guy (Christian never touched anyone either, remember) But Christian wasn’t close enough to the REAL OTHERS to pull off getting their leader to kill Jacob.
When Ben’s daughter appeared to him in the basement of the temple, that was really Jacob. She grabbed Ben, therefore can’t be the black shirt dude. Jacob knew what was going on (I get the impression he knows everything about the island) and went along with it for reasons to be discovered in Season 6. Jacob isn’t really dead.
Season 6 will commence with telling the story of Jacob and the black shirt dude in the flashbacks, and the black shirt dude, wounded jacob, and naked Oceanic 815 passengers in the present day.
Comment #19 by AmyMay 18th, 2009 at 8:28 amI cANNOT BELIEVE we have to wait nine months. It’s a gestation, for pete’s sake!
I feel like I have to figure out now which events/ghosts/happenings were influenced by jacob, and which by not jacob. makes a big difference.
I really want juliet to be back next season. I am totally digging juliet and sawyer this season. maybe they are the “adam/eve” skeletons they found in an earlier season.
hoping to get answers next year, but what will I obsess over when it’s gone??
oh, and I just found this blog. pretty cool!
Comment #20 by Amy SMay 20th, 2009 at 8:52 pmAmy