By Heather O.
I should probably write this post when I have time to be introspective, and funny, or poignant, or both. And since I don’t have time or the patience to really think everything out, and I’m not really sure what I want to say about Mother’s Day anyways, I thought maybe pushing myself to do a post in the 15 minutes I have before I take Little Sister to her swimming lesson would force me to pull it altogether in one big…something. Something big and cohesive. Like, a big, um, stone, um, whatever.
Basically, what I want to say is that Mother’s Day is a hard and complicated and potentially painful holiday, and I want to explore why.
This topic was sparked in my head after reading what a friend of mine had to say about Mother’s Day on her FB wall. She has given birth to 4 little people–2 girls, 2 boys. She relinquished her first daughter, however, for adoption, and her daughter, now almost a grown woman herself, was raised by adoptive parents. An open adoption plan didn’t work out the way it was supposed to, and my friend has spent almost 2 decades trying to wrap her brain and her soul and her heart around the whole thing. It hasn’t been easy for her, and in direct contrast to what she was told as a young single pregnant teenager, time has not healed this wound. As you can imagine, she looks forward to Mother’s Day almost as much as a root canal.
Another friend of mine found out when she was a teenager that she is physically incapable of having children, and while she is an awesome step-mother to her husband’s son, I’m sure that Mother’s Day isn’t an easy day for her, either.
I know a lot of women who simply don’t go to church on Mother’s Day sunday, because it’s too much for them. And I know that bishoprics spend months in advance trying to figure out what to do on Mother’s Day Sunday, with full knowledge that anything they do has the potential to offend or hurt somebody. My cousin, a former bishop, told a story of how his brother, a full-time stay at home dad, was asked to speak on Mother’s Day, and he got up and said, “Mothers, I feel your pain.” My cousin said that as a bishop, Mother’s Day is THE hardest Sunday to plan, and he said he wished he had such a slam dunk speaker as his brother in HIS ward.
Mother’s Day. Complicated for men AND women.
It seems like a simple idea–yay for moms! We are awesome! Look at us! Look at how we sacrifice and slave and work and do everything we can to make sure our children don’t grow up to be lazy jerks! We are mothers and we rock the cradle and that means we RULE THE WORLD!!!! Bow to us, our minions!!
(Okay, maybe nobody says that, but c’mon, you know minions would be cool.)
But even I, who came from a stable family and have an awesome mom feel squirmy on Mother’s Day. Like I’m not good enough. Like I’m not doing enough. That there is something I’m missing, and that if THEY ONLY KNEW, I wouldn’t be getting that wilted flower from the young deacon that passed me the Sacrament just an hour before. They would take my flower from me and say, “Dude, you let your 4 year old watch “My Little Pony” for hours this week, and you KNOW there is all KINDS of inter-relational aggression messages in that show, and you are just priming her to grow up to be a Mean Girl, and that if you were a better mother you would have been teaching her Latin instead. NO FLOWER FOR YOU!”
And though I’ve never talked to her about it, I wonder how my mom feels about being honored. She raised 6 kids and we all turned out okay, with only a mild amount of craziness (but what family isn’t a little insane–i mean, really). I asked her once what she did to keep her family intact and active in the church and generally void of massive self-destructive behavior, and she and my dad both look at each other and shrug and say, “We don’t know.” See? Even SHE doesn’t know the secret, and not a single one of HER children EVER stuck playdough up his or her nose, which is not something I can say for my offspring.
Anyway, my allotted time is up. I have to go be the mom who takes my kid to swim practice, although I must admit that I’m also the mom who will be late for swim practice because I was blogging.
Yes, I am that mom. NO FLOWER FOR ME!
Mother’s Day–discuss.




I wish that Mother’s Day could be easier for more Mormon moms knowing that motherhood, and the ability to have children isn’t limited to just this life.
Comment #1 by StrollerbladerMay 10th, 2012 at 10:34 amApparently my bishop just wants to pretend it isn’t Mother’s day at all. I’ve been asked to speak in sacrament meeting and base my talk on a conference address about adversity. Maybe I am talking about motherhood after all. It feels a little weird to not talk about Mothers but maybe it’s the best way to not offend, I’m ok with it.
Comment #2 by JenneferMay 10th, 2012 at 10:35 amI really don’t understand why there should talks at Sacrament Meeting about mothers on Mother’s Day anyway. Shouldn’t we talk about the Savior and the gospel? Wouldn’t that pretty much solve the problem?
And as for gifts for mothers on that day, why not have the ward donate the allotted money to the local women’s shelter? (That’s what my ward in NY did and it was an awesome thing.) Awkward problem of passing out flowers or whatever crap solved. And a women’s shelter would really benefit from the money more so than women tormented by mother’s guilt.
Comment #3 by Tiffany W.May 10th, 2012 at 12:25 pmI love this post. A lot.
I think it’s complicated too. All the saccharine stuff doesn’t ring true, but neither does the whining about how hard motherhood is.
Comment #4 by Emily M.May 10th, 2012 at 2:27 pmMy husband asked me just yesterday, “What do you want for Mother’s Day. I want to make sure you feel appreciated.”
I just couldn’t think of anything besides “Make sure the kids clean up after themselves. And they can make dinner. And clean up that.”
I’m so sick of Mother’s Day. I wish it didn’t exist. Not that I don’t want appreciation, but… What you said.
Comment #5 by mormonhermitmomMay 10th, 2012 at 3:33 pmI agree. I’m not a big fan. I’m even less of a fan because not only is my mother (who is also single so no husband to defer the attention too) close by but my husband’s mom, my step mom and my grandma. AND this year my mil’s birthday falls on mother’s day. Its just too much pressure for me! I want a “day off” but in order to do that someone gets left out or forgotten. I wish I could be like my brother and sister and not live close to anyone so a phone call is sufficient.
Comment #6 by flip flop mamaMay 10th, 2012 at 3:53 pmThe sugguestion to donate to a women’s shelter is a wonderful idea that I will carry to our ward council. However, I am sure someone would be offended that they didn’t get their flower this year,however. So I don’t think it will fly. Dear flip flop mama for the first time in our life we live close enough to the various Mothers and feel responsible for the celebrations.I see the problem and privilege that brings. I have also hated Mother’s Day for all the years I have been a mother and wish that day would just disappear.
Comment #7 by rae keckMay 10th, 2012 at 4:05 pmFor some reason, Mother’s Day highlights all of the resentment I feel as a mom and some of the gender equality issues I have at church. “I have to do the dishes on Mother’s Day?” (when I normally wouldn’t care…) and “I have to work in primary with other people’s kids on Mother’s Day and what should be my only day off of the entire year?”
I always tell my DH the only thing I want is to NOT have to figure out a gift for HIS mom!
Comment #8 by JenMay 10th, 2012 at 4:11 pmI’ve always felt that we kind of take the wrong perspective on Mother’s Day in Sacrament. Now, if we could have a Mother’s Day Sacrament meeting based on this: http://squaretwo.org/Sq2ArticleCasslerPaulsenPulido.html
Comment #9 by EmilyMay 10th, 2012 at 8:12 pmwell, that would just be AWESOME!
I hate being asked “What do you want for Mother’s Day?” I’m not gift greedy. I don’t really care what, or if anything, you buy me. But if I have to tell you what to go buy, it kinda negates the whole thoughtful gift giving thing, right? Just make some kind of an effort to do something on your own, and I’m good. Also, our ward has done away with flowers or candy passed out awkwardly after sacrament meeting. Instead, all women are excused from Sunday school and their callings second hour and are invited to the cultural hall for refreshments-milk, juice, fruit, danishes, cookies, etc. ALL women are invited and get to relax and visit freely with each other. It’s quite lovely!
Comment #10 by TiffanyMay 11th, 2012 at 7:54 amMy MIL’s ward donated money to…I forget what, but some worthy cause instead of giving the moms the traditional wilted flower on Mother’s Day. It DID NOT GO OVER WELL. I say, Bishops, donate away! If you dare. I think it’s a great idea, but I think mothers whose ONLY identity is being mothers won’t be down with it.
Comment #11 by MollyMay 11th, 2012 at 11:13 amMy ward in NY has been donating to the women’s shelter for a long time in lieu of treats or gifts to the mothers. Sure, the first year, people may be offended, but I think they’ll get over it.
Comment #12 by Tiffany W.May 11th, 2012 at 11:46 amMakes me mad that people will be offended over not getting a flower, as opposed to giving money to women who are in desperate circumstances. Really??? Do you really need a wilted flower from your ward to feel appreciated as a mother or as a woman?
My ward in NY has been donating to the women’s shelter for a long time in lieu of treats or gifts to the mothers. Sure, the first year, people may be offended, but I think they’ll get over it.
Comment #13 by Tiffany W.May 11th, 2012 at 11:46 amMakes me mad that people will be offended over not getting a flower, as opposed to giving money to women who are in desperate circumstances. Really??? Do you really need a wilted flower from your ward to feel appreciated as a mother or as a woman?
I didn’t marry until I was almost 30 and didn’t have kids until I was 33. Of course there were lessons in Church about marriage and motherhood while I was single. We also celebrated Mother’s Day in Sacrament Meeting. Inevitably there were women who would leave the meeting or not even attend when they learned what the lesson subject was. I don’t understand this. Why can’t we celebrate the beauty of motherhood and marriage even if it’s not our specific blessing at the time? There’s enough negativity in the world - let’s celebrate each other’s blessings instead of dwelling on the things we don’t have.
Comment #14 by LisaMay 11th, 2012 at 12:24 pmI am not a mother (8 yrs of trying) but am a stepmother to 3. I am not currently an active member. I totally get how painful it is, but have to agree with Lisa, sort of. Some one shouldn’t have to hide their accomplishments/gifts/blessings because someone else didn’t get the same. I’m trying to teach my kids that life isn’t fair, not everyone gets a trophy….etc.
But dumped the crappy flowers and meaningless platitudes. Do something real to honor mothers/women.
Comment #15 by wendyMay 11th, 2012 at 2:20 pmI like Mother’s Day. I’ve always known that Mother’s Day makes some mothers feel crappy, well ever since I was in high school.
Comment #16 by jksMay 11th, 2012 at 4:14 pmMy husband and kids are nice to me. They even understood when I told them a few years ago to stop making me breakfast in bed because I normally don’t eat first thing in the morning. So they are just nice and appreciative all day long. What’s not to like?
Church is more often good than bad. Occasional bad clueless speakers who seem to have written something to intentionally hurt half of the audience, but sometimes very good ones. The last part of Releif Society we have dessert and socialize. It is very nice.
I’m with JKS. I also like Mother’s Day. A day off and a bit of pampering is nice. I know I’m not a perfect mother, but so far I’ve never felt like it’s a day that highlights my shortcomings.
Comment #17 by AndreaMay 11th, 2012 at 4:27 pmWhat’s with all the hate? I get that Mother’s Day is hard for some. I REALLY REALLY REALLY do, but why do we always have to be angry about everything? My comment IS NOT about Mother’s Day. This is about confronting something that you aren’t feeling so hip about and choosing not to let it bother you on any level. Not because you are choosing not to be offended, but because it isn’t a big enough deal to get offended. Stop the hate, be grateful for what is offered to you at any time (a flower, a crappy breakfast, a talk haltingly given with words that may not be appreciated) with a loving heart. I’m sick of members thinking that just because they are part of a ward that they have a right to complain about what happens. Your bishop is more worried about the single mom struggling to pay her rent or the family with the teen that is sliding down a slippery slope than what you think about x,y, or z happenings in the ward. At least he would be if people would take the service offered without complaining.
Comment #18 by Fed Up!May 12th, 2012 at 7:56 amI hated Mothers Day until I had a kid, both due to ten years of infertility, but before that 30 years of fighting with my mother every Mothers Day. I get now that we would fight due to her own insecurities as a mother, but it was the worst day of the year for years. Now I love having her make me a gift at school, and I love when she has me sit down and wear a tiara and open my gifts.
Comment #19 by m2thehMay 12th, 2012 at 1:35 pm“What’s not to like?”
It’s the fakey forcedness of it with which I have a problem.
Right now my teenagers treat me like crap, they are personally abusive and demeaning to me. Because my older children have turned into lovely people, I am sure that this batch of kids will also get over it, eventually, and decide that either I am not so stupid as they thought, or that I somehow got smarter in a few years:)
Doing one nice thing on part of one day of the 365 in the year does not make me feel the least bit better about the garbage they put be through during the rest of the year.
That said, I don’t have a problem with celebrations at church, and I certainly don’t want to rain on anyone else’s parade and would never say anything to anyone. If you enjoy it, great. Just don’t expect me to as well.
“Not because you are choosing not to be offended, but because it isn’t a big enough deal to get offended. ”
We need to be careful about not judging others. Whether it is a big enough deal to get offended or not is a personal call. And a lot of times the reason people skip church etc. is not offense per se, but knowing one’s limits.
Comment #20 by NaismithMay 12th, 2012 at 7:21 pmCurrently on year 4 of infertility, countless medical procedures and one failed adoption - that’s why I hate Mother’s Day. I love my own mother dearly and admire my friends who are mothers and all they have to deal with. But right now, as I struggle to realize that at 36 (didn’t marry until 31) I will likely never have children, Mother’s Day is just an incredibly painful reminder of something that I will not get to experience. I hope and pray that at some point this hurt isn’t so raw but right now it’s all I could do to face the day on Sunday.
Comment #21 by JELMay 14th, 2012 at 8:49 pmLove you, JEL. Thought of you on Mother’s Day, too…
Comment #22 by Heather O.May 15th, 2012 at 3:38 pmWihtout reading any of the comments and thus potentially (read: most definitely) stepping on some toes, here are my 2 cents.
This sorta reminds me of how there are now little leagues where they don’t keep score, and nobody wins and everyone gets a trophy.
I agree that this can be one of those tender, complicated holidays. BUT WHAT ISN’T? In fact lets pick a topic, any topic and I bet we can find someone, somewhere who is offended, hurt, sad, angry by that topic. Forgive me, but sometimes I feel that it is just too much to try and avoid all hurt feelings, awkward, etc. People are too dang afraid of being hurt and feeling pain on almost any level. Perhaps I’m making a huge leap here, but I think this easy breezey lifestyle we enjoy in the US has made us physical and emotional sissy’s and avoiding pain can cause us more harm than just dealing with the initial pain. Drink this, take that….make the pain go away.
I feel that we place too much responsibility on the shoulders of others (the Bishop, etc) to make sure our feelings aren’t hurt. For me this is the same issue of someone getting offended in church over any random comment and instead of putting the responsibility on themselves to deal with it (blow it off, ask to speak to the offender one on one, pray about it, etc) they find a way to make in a bigger issue (stop coming to church, avoid the offender at all costs, go to the Bishop).
Just to clarify, I’m not saying people can’t have a hard time with Mother’s Day. I understand and get it, if it’s a painful holiday for you–even if you feel you just can’t face church on that day. What I don’t like, is making it hard or difficult for anyone to enjoy and celebrate what is a nice holiday for many (like being angry/upset at the gift given in church, talks, etc).
Comment #23 by MiggyMay 16th, 2012 at 12:04 pmI totally agree, Miggy, with all of it.
Comment #24 by StarababaMay 16th, 2012 at 8:22 pmAre you saying there are problems BIGGER THAN MOTHER’S DAY, Miggy? Sheesh, how dare you.
Comment #25 by Heather O.May 17th, 2012 at 12:58 pmAmen Miggy!
Comment #26 by Tiffany W.May 19th, 2012 at 5:23 amAmen Miggy!
Comment #27 by Tiffany W.May 19th, 2012 at 5:23 am