By Heather O.
We talk about Belief Windows sometimes in my family, mostly because my dad wrote a book with that title in it somewhere a zillion years ago. I’d like to say I read the book, but I didn’t. I’m a bad daughter.
But, as I understand it, it’s just a way of defining how we view the world. We put on our lenses of our own beliefs, and look at the world through the lenses. It’s the idea that we all define our own reality, because we bring to our own reality our own sets of beliefs and experiences. The idea is that we can change our belief windows, and thus change our realities, our attitudes, our actions, our life path, whatever.
Basically, I think it’s just a nice way of saying that we are all kidding ourselves. And nobody kids herself more than a mother about her own children.
For example, I have 5 siblings–3 sisters, 2 brothers. 3 of us have blonde hair. 3 of us do not. It’s not all that surprising, really, given that my mother was blonde as a child, and my father was not. Genetics. They’re fun.
I have blonde hair. I have always had blonde hair. I now pay for it to be that color (because really there is not a hair color less attractive than what can only be accurately described as dirty dishwater), but all growing up, and even in college, I was unquestionably a blonde. And despite having married a redhead who came from a family of brunettes, my children both have ridiculously light blonde hair.
My sister is not a blonde. She never has been. She has dabbled with different hair colors in her life, including getting almost sort of close to blonde, and has now settled on a nice darker auburn-ish shade that fits her skin tone very nicely. Her three children are all brunettes.
My mother claims all her children are blonde.
It’s silly, really, because there is photographic proof, dating back to when we were all very young, that disputes her claim. And yet she says she has never given birth to a brunette. My sister finally called her on it, saying that my mother has a belief window that only blondes are beautiful, thus her children must have been blondes. My sister accused my mother of thinking brunettes are less attractive than blondes. My mother disagreed, saying of course brunettes are beautiful too, but her belief window is that all of her children are blonde.
Reality vs. Belief Window clash. Which one will win?
I was thinking about this because I have to put my daughter’s hair up in a “ballet bun” for her ballet performance this weekend, and it involves using a hair net, something that never entered in my own ballet performance experience. Also, Little Sister has only now begun to look like somebody didn’t take a weed whacker to her hair after the Very Unfortunate Hair Cut of last summer, and putting her short hair into a bun is going to be a tricky. So, I googled “ballet bun”, and came across a very nice video of a mom doing her daughter’s hair. Her daughter is a beautiful little girl with gorgeous, dark brown hair. Her mother stressed the importance of getting hair accessories that matched, and held up a BLONDE hair tie. She said that since her daughter’s hair is strawberry blonde, this hair tie matches nicely. She then put it in her daughter’s hair, and IT DIDN’T MATCH AT ALL. This girl was a beautiful little girl, but strawberry blonde she was not.
Reality vs. Belief Window clash.
I’ve seen other parents do this. A mom at preschool who calls her son “gentle and tender-hearted”, even he hit kids on the playground and throws sand in their faces. Another mom who says that her son is “shy and quiet”, even as he shouts insults at my kid. Another mom who worries that her daughter is a “follower”, even as she bosses other children around. Friends who are teachers tell me that parents wear blinders about their children all the time, and that it’s sad when the only person who is surprised when a kid goes off the deep-end is the parent who refused to believe that her kid was capable of self-destructive behavior.
Reality vs. Belief Window Clash.
We do this about ourselves, too. I know talkers who say they are good listeners. I know idle people who claim they live an active lifestyle. I know fat people who claim they are thin, thin people who claim they are fat, rude people who think they are kind, kind people who agonize because they are not doing enough. And women probably do it more than men, but I could just think that because I talk to more women than men.
But mothers, we are the worst.
Do you think it’s possible to see our children for who they really are? I think we do them a disservice when we try to make them into something they are not, like telling a brunette she is really a strawberry blonde, because what message does that tell to the girl who knows what she really is? If we see our children for who they really are, we can help them in their actual struggles, not the struggles we make up, or wish they had, or wish they didn’t have. Is it possible to rewrite our beliefs when it comes to the most important people in our lives, even if they turn out not to be exactly the kids we thought or wanted them to be? Can we love them anyways, even if they aren’t as gentle as we would like, or hard working as we would like, or successful in the way we had hoped?
At the very least, we should be able to get their hair color right.




My MIL is the queen of revisionist history, what we call Belief Windows in our family. DH was very sick earlier this year and after two different ER visits, they kept him in an ICU room for several days. He was almost completely out of it (insisting on doing “work from his hospital bed” even though that work was written completely incoherently and largely without verbs) and a couple of months ago when we were ruminating on that crazy time in our lives, he asked his mother if she visited him in the hospital. She said, “Of course I did, I was there every morning and every afternoon, that is how worried we were about you!” I bit my tongue, knowing that the important part of the sentence was that she was worried about her son and that he know it. But after they left, when my husband marveled on how out of it he must have been to have no memory of so many visits, I corrected the vision–she came one morning and another afternoon. And spent the better part of a morning calling me from her office telling me what all the nurses she works with (She’s a social worker in a hospice facility) thought might be wrong with her son. He was relieved to know the truth, that he wasn’t entirely delirious.
I think as mothers, we want to be perceived as doing the best job possible. Part of that is knowing our children, caring for them, but also sometimes we cross the line to believing that “the best job possible” means having the most perfectly behaved child, because that reflects well on us. It’s like the little kid who lies and says they didn’t steal the candy bar, only because they so desperately wish they hadn’t done it that they believe saying it makes it so: magical thinking. It is a terrifying message we send our children when we do this and one we must be vigilant to root out.
Hair color is a funny thing though; often it is about degrees. I served my mission in Brazil, where the only natural light blondes are in the south where German ancestry is common. For most of the rest of the country, it is far more common to have hair colors range from black to brown to a sun-reddened auburn with a dishwater blonde at the northern, and somewhat unusual extreme. Anything that is north of this auburny shade they often call “blonde” One of my companion’s father had some European ancestry in him (by way of Argentina, I think), so her hair was a lighter shade of brown, but not even reaching dishwater. She was regularly called blonde. I am very fair and while on my mission, became almost a platinum blonde because of the sun. I married a guy who has similar coloring, so the range of hair color in our family is whitey-platinum to darker blonde, but still north of dishwater (ash blonde?). My 13yo daughter has the ash blonde version and for years she would tell people she had “dark brown” hair because it was so much darker (to her mind) than her brothers’ and sister’s hair. Our hair stylist laughs at this and shows her those fake hair swatches for hair color, to show her that her hair is empirically not dark brown, but she doesn’t see it, really even now. Belief Windows are powerful things.
Comment #1 by angie fJune 1st, 2012 at 11:47 amI love this Heather. I’ve been thinking about it a lot lately, I even have a post in my drafts that sort of dances around this but never quite nails it down like you just did, especially in that second to last paragraph.
My middle daughter is a lot like me, to an almost scary degree (she even looks exactly like I did - we could’ve been twins), but I have to continually remind myself that she is NOT ACTUALLY ME. I have to smack myself around a little to be sure that I’m really seeing her and her normal kid behavior and not projecting things from my own childhood. Just because she wants an extra snack doesn’t mean she’s inevitably headed for an eating disorder. Just because she can be bossy and tempermental sometimes doesn’t mean that she will turn into a teenage beast like I did (or maybe she will, who knows, but she will be her OWN teenage beast). Really it just means she’s a kid.
Parenting based on fears that your children will inevitably go through all of the exact same crap you went through and have the exact same problems you had is probably a bad idea.
Belief windows. That’s perfect, so thank you.
Comment #2 by Sue MJune 1st, 2012 at 11:49 amOh, and about hair color and such - two of my kids have green eyes, and the third was born with green eyes that turned hazel and then brown. But I didn’t believe they were brown for the longest time. To me, they looked green. Then one day my sister-in-law looked at me and said, “You’re crazy. THEY ARE BROWN.” And all of a sudden, they were.
Denial is a powerful thing.
Comment #3 by Sue MJune 1st, 2012 at 11:52 amFor the longest time I thought my youngest daughter’s hair was dark brown- and when she was first born, it was, but it has lightened. I think the reason why is because my older daughter’s hair is light brown and she has blue eyes; my younger daughter has brown eyes (like me), so that just seemed to flip a switch in my brain that she’d have dark hair like me too. But one day I was looking at them next to each other and I realized that their hair is actually the exact same color. I pointed it out to my mother and she did a double-take- she had been thinking the same thing I had!
I agree with Sue M.- it can be a dangerous thing to parent based on the labels we put on our children. My son is a lot like my brother was- he’s very into Legos and reading. My brother never got into sports, and never developed any kind of sports ability, which I now realize was probably a result of my parents’ lack of interest in sports. My husband is a sports fanatic, and he wanted my son to do baseball. I was hesitant, but I agreed that he could try it if he wanted to. I didn’t have very high expectations. However, my son thought it might be fun to try and he had a lot of fun with it, and certainly had at least average ability. If he continues to enjoy it I can certainly see him getting very good at it.
I think the important thing is to let kids be who they’re going to be, and emphasize their best qualities and the qualities you hope to see in them. Our opinions of them often become their identities, and while it’s important to not kid ourselves (especially when it comes to discipline issues), it’s also important that they know we think they’re awesome so that they can see the good in themselves and know we’re their biggest fans.
Comment #4 by KaseyJune 1st, 2012 at 1:24 pmMy hair growing up was light blonde. It has darkened over the years especially since having kids. I didn’t realize how dark it had gotten until I was planning out halloween costumes one year and was considering being goldilocks. My husband pointed out my hair was not the right color. I took a good look at it and realized how much it had changed…
What’s funny is that my oldest daughter has the exact same hair color as me but she calls my hair brown and her hair blonde…
Comment #5 by KarlaJune 1st, 2012 at 1:50 pmMy son says his hair is blonde and his sister’s is brown. Of course, it is the exact same color. A fascinating post. And a bit frightening.
Comment #6 by KatieJune 1st, 2012 at 3:03 pm“Our opinions of them often become their identities.”
YES.
Comment #7 by Sue MJune 1st, 2012 at 4:59 pm“Our opinions of them often become their identities.”
YES.
Comment #8 by Sue MJune 1st, 2012 at 4:59 pmMy dh teases me all the time for thinking I’m still a blondie because I was blonde all the way thru high school. But it is most definitely dishwater blonde now, bordering on brown, and even though I see it in the mirror every day I still picture myself as that little girl that people used to call Goldilocks once upon a time.
And until I read this I didn’t realize that I’ve been stereotyping my oldest daughter because she’s so like me and so her weaknesses bug me more than my other kids’ because I think they’re my weaknesses. But she isn’t me, and I need to lighten up on her or she will become my weaknesses. God help me with that one!
Comment #9 by StarababaJune 2nd, 2012 at 10:23 pmI used to think my hair was a lot lighter than it was until a friend straightened me out. The funniest part was the look on her face when I told her what color I thought my hair was
Now it’s whatever I want it to be, cause it comes out of a box! As for parents seeing how their kids really are, I experience this first hand with my DH’s kids. He sees them one way, and I see them completely different because, well, they aren’t mine. Not that they are bad or problems, but we see them different. I think of it like when you are looking at something a little too close, it’s really fuzzy, but once you back off, what you are looking at becomes a little more clear.
Comment #10 by TrixieJune 4th, 2012 at 11:18 amThe scariest example with the most unfortunate effect i know of was the case of my brother, father of twelve, who believes that the “quality” of his children was determined by how “righteous” he, personally, was at the time of the child’s conception. He was convinced that the daughter born while he was engaged in behavior that led to his excommunication the following year was a “bad seed” and he treated her accordingly, from the time she was an infant, while those born after his return were naturally humble and faithful. That girl is brilliant, beautiful, kind, the most wonderful mother, and I love her very much. She has had some rocky times, not surprisingly, and it’s only due to how special she really is that she wasn’t completely overcome by her father’s irrational and unjustifiable “belief window” to become the wayward child he still treats her as being.
Comment #11 by Anon this timeJune 5th, 2012 at 7:31 pmFirst off, I want the actual title of your dad’s book because I think it would be immensely enjoyed by my father-in-law, and Father’s Day is approaching and we don’t have a gift for him yet….is it available on amazon??
Second of all, where does this blond thing come from? My husband’s family does it too, and his mom is still “blond” curtesy of the hairdresser when all her siblings are mouse brown. Her mom bleached her hair into her seventies, so that she would never be brunette. They insist all my husband’s siblings were blond (including him) even though there is photo evidence of my husband as a newborn, 2 month old, 6 month old, 1 year old, 2 year old, etc….with dark brown hair. I don’t get it.
Comment #12 by AmyJune 7th, 2012 at 10:19 amI think that emotional investment muddies the water of any relationship. And if we are emotionally invested in anything, it’s our kids. I think I’ve got blind spots about mine, sometimes. I certainly worry about them more than I need to.
I had to laugh at your description of yourself as “always a blonde.” Me too. What is it about blonde hair that is so salient to our identity? I feel it too, but I don’t quite understand it. And I’ve even told my husband that if my hair ever got darker (btw, mine hasn’t yet… I must have supercharged viking genes) I’d keep dying it blond because I wouldn’t know myself otherwise.
Comment #13 by Sarah DunsterJune 23rd, 2012 at 8:25 pmNot only do I have “belief windows”, but I am also a major participant in memory editing and motive assigning! Gotta stop all that…gonna need grace to get it done!
Comment #14 by LeciaJuly 6th, 2012 at 8:04 amNot only do I have “belief windows”, but I am also a major participant in memory editing and motive assigning! Gotta stop all that…gonna need grace to get it done!
Comment #15 by LeciaJuly 6th, 2012 at 8:04 amThere is a wonderful lady in my ward who never knew she had dark brown hair until she was a teenager. Her mom had always dyed it blonde since she was an infant.
Comment #16 by TStevensJuly 24th, 2012 at 6:25 am