By Heather O.
J’s fondest dream came true today. He had a play date with his favorite friend.
This friend has, among other things, a beautiful house, a trampoline with big fun beach balls and a net attached, remote control cars, and, the most glittering jewel in the crown, Game Cube.
DH and I have strong feelings about video games, and have decided not to purchase any for our home. I have no problem with him playing them at other people’s houses, however, and he spent a blissful hour and a half clicking away while his friend’s mom and I chatted about what colors she was going to paint her totally white walls.
When it came time to leave, J had a massive melt down because he didn’t want to go. Not unusual, of course, and we eventually made it to the car as he cried and cried about leaving the people he loves most in the world. And, naturally, the devastating loss of the Game Cube.
“I don’t have any kids to play with in my family!” he cried when we got into the car.
True, he doesn’t. The hyper dog just doesn’t suffice as a sibling, and any sibling we could procure in the future would be a pretty poor playmate for a while.
“I don’t have a Game Cube!” he wailed.
True, he doesn’t, for a variety of reasons.
“I don’t want to go home because I don’t have a tramp!”
True, he doesn’t. No particular reason, we just don’t. I’m rolling my eyes and trying to console him, half hearing him, half agreeing with him, half nodding my head, etc.
“I hate my toys! And I need more! I don’t have enough!”
At that point, I almost snapped. Not enough? Not enough? I’ll show you not enough. I told him sternly that even though we didn’t have the things that the other family had, I never, ever wanted to hear him say that he didn’t have enough.
He was stunned enough from my sudden switch in tone that he momentarily stopped wailing, and I wondered just what he was thinking. I was even mad enough to say, “If you don’t like your toys, I’m sure that we can find somebody who does.” Someday I’d love to honor that threat, just to see what would happen.
He was therefore silent, either too scared to say another word for fear of losing his toys, or because he found the half eaten bag of M&M’s he had opened earlier, and decided it needed finishing. Either way, no more wailing.
I’m trying to look at the situation objectively, and realize that this was a tired boy who was having fun whose life was interupted by his mother’s schedule. It’s close to dinner time, he had been running hard most of the day, and life was just a little too much for him at that point. It’s just a child talking, but still, it makes me a little sick to think that he can look at his entire playroom full of toys and say, “I don’t have enough.”
Maybe he picks that up from us, I don’t know. I’m sure there are plenty of signals I send out about not having enough that I’m unaware of. Still, I want to make sure that I don’t raise an ungrateful brat who decides that unless he has it all, it’s just not enough. Because with that attitude, he will always need more. And more is a scary word.






Amen sister!
Comment #1 by lizJanuary 15th, 2007 at 7:08 pmOther kid’s toys are always cooler.
Comment #2 by The WizJanuary 15th, 2007 at 7:18 pmSounds like your reaction was exactly right.
Comment #3 by Tracy MJanuary 15th, 2007 at 7:19 pmI remember when my oldest was about 9, his best friend was an only child of divorced parents. This kid’s parents lived ten minutes away from each other, and they traded him off every week. So my son would go play at both of the parents’ places. His friend basically had twice as much stuff as most kids would—a room full of stuff at his mom’s and a room full of stuff at his dad’s.
My son told me how cool he thought it was, and I could tell he was envious of all the stuff. (We could never afford much when the kids were smaller.)
I said, “Yeah. Maybe your dad and I should get divorced.” Then I got mean: “Who would you want to live with if we got divorced?”
Poor kid. What a mean mom.
Comment #4 by Susan MJanuary 15th, 2007 at 7:20 pmIf it makes you feel better I remember recieving chastisement like this from my mom (on more than one occasion, actually). Those chastisements were heartfelt and have stayed with me and helped me to be better about keeping my wants/needs/greed in perspective, and being more aware of the things other kids wanted that I was lucky enough to have.
Comment #5 by StarfoxyJanuary 15th, 2007 at 8:17 pmOne day I was complaining about the scratches on my dining room table, only to have my 5 yr old daughter remark matter of factly, “Mom, I guess we’ll just have to get a new one.”
A NEW ONE?
I was thinking…Oh my gosh, have I actually been raising you to think that it doesn’t matter when something gets damaged, we can always get a new one?
I have the same worries about raising a spoiled child and I REALLY truly hope we curb it fast, because it’s a major problem as the years go on and they get smarter!
Comment #6 by Rachel HJanuary 15th, 2007 at 8:59 pmThe Wiz is right. Other kids’ toys are always cooler. But like you said, he’s probably tired and hungry, and after such a big day of playing with some totally cool toys, he feels very deprived. Personally if that happened to me with my son, I’d probably lecture him the first time and if it happened again, I’d be tempted to take everything away and make him earn it all back or ask him which TWO toys he wanted to keep.
My brother gave his two very young boys $500 worth of toys each for Christmas. He can’t afford that. I know that I can’t afford that. And if I could, I still wouldn’t do it. What happens when they’ve had everything there is to have, remain ungrateful and maybe turn to drugs?
Compared to my neighbors, we don’t have many toys. But when I look around the house, it’s far too many between my three kids. So I put away half of them and rotate them about every 4-6 weeks. Then there’s always newness to their toys and they appreciate them more. And there’s not so many out that they get overwhelmed, dump them all over, and not play with them. Or not be able to find their favorites.
Comment #7 by NikkiJanuary 15th, 2007 at 9:38 pmMy kid is only 6 months old, but he already has more toys than he needs. All he does is rollover and drool. Do you really need a Backyardagin for that?? My plan, hopefully, is to let the gramps know that instead of a ton of toys, put the money in an account just for him. I will use it for clothes and things like sports registration/shoes, etc. I am not sure if that will work yet, but I’m hopin’.
Sounds like you did a killer job to me, keep it up mama!
Comment #8 by AmyJanuary 15th, 2007 at 9:48 pmInteresting idea, Amy. I’ve asked my family to donate to things before in lieu of gifts for me, but never thought of making an account for my son–duh. Maybe I’ll try that next birthday. He definitely doesn’t need something like a new action figure!
Comment #9 by Heather O.January 15th, 2007 at 10:42 pmOr maybe even you as the parents only do one or two things for the birthday and then also put some money into and accout. Or you might get lucky and have a kid that is OBSESSED with pajamas right now so that’s all he’s getting for his B-day in a couple of weeks. No more toys to clutter and he will be a happy camper.
Comment #10 by AmberJanuary 15th, 2007 at 11:05 pmI’ve actually carried thru on the threat. They would whine and complain that they didn’t have anything to play with, they hated all their toys, they needed something more than they already had, it was too hard to clean up their toys, etc. So i got onto our local freecycle group after sorting thru their toys and decimating it by half and the toys were gone w/in 24 hours. i’m a mean mom and proud of it! i’d rather spend my time playing with my kids and enjoying them than hearing whining.
Comment #11 by AlisonJanuary 15th, 2007 at 11:07 pmI got gifts from my parents and from both sets of grandparents and I wasn’t ruined. Let the Grandparents have the fun of buying things for their grandbabies- if that’s what they want to do. If my kids have too many toys it’s my own fault and not my parents. Just before Christmas we cleaned out the basement toy room and made donations. That helped to not have so much down there after Christmas. I also like the idea of rotating toys.
Comment #12 by AmberJanuary 15th, 2007 at 11:09 pmI have an awesome friend who, from the time her two girls were really young, would have them choose charities to have relatives donate to in lieu of gifts. Of course, grandma hated the idea, but got used to it when she saw the the kids were actually sincere about it.
As for me, we have the same talks and the same problems. As teachers in a private school, my kids get the benefit of free tuition. This means that most of their playmates are a lot more privileged than we are. How many times have my children gone to a playdate where they had to bring their swimsuit? How many times do I hear about so-and-so’s private bathroom? (my kids are in kinder and 2nd grade). It’s tough, but it sounds like you handled the situation in a really good way! And anyway, my kids are always whining when they’ve played too long and are tired!
Comment #13 by meemsJanuary 16th, 2007 at 2:13 amI tried the “account” thing instead of a gift- the grandparents HATE the idea… they don’t want to help pay for college in 18 years- they wanna give the Monkeys STUFF, and NOW… what can I say. I’ve thrown my hands up.
Comment #14 by Tracy MJanuary 16th, 2007 at 2:18 amAnother idea to avoid getting so much stuff is what my parents do. Of course this only works if you live reasonably close to the grandparents, but they take the birthday child out to a play or ice skating or some special event with just them and the child. My kids have LOVED it and don’t miss the lack of stuff.
Comment #15 by Andrea WrightJanuary 16th, 2007 at 11:29 amI think you handled the meltdown well!
Comment #16 by cchrissyyJanuary 16th, 2007 at 2:12 pmwe often discuss how DS needs to take good care of his toys (don’t break them, leave them a mess, get them dirty) or else I will give to them to another kid who will. It’s not an empty threat at all -we also frequently discuss how if we ever have food or money that we don’t need, then Heavenly Father sent it to us so we would give it to somebody who needs it more. It’s the same with toys- if DS doesn’t really care for the toys, it’s our responsibility to get them to the right kid.
Tracy M,
Comment #17 by NancyJanuary 16th, 2007 at 4:17 pmWe are also in the process of asking grandparents to donate to a college fund–the grandparents, as yours are, want to give stuff and give it now–they want to be remembered for the stuff they give their grandkids, not helping the education.
So if you find a way to solve the problem peacefully, please let me know.
Nancy
You know, I talked with my inlaws about the whole gift-giving thing this Christmas. i made the comment to them that I don’t remember what was given to me when I was 6 and I know it will be the same for my kids. It’s more about the memories. i like the idea of the grandparents taking the kids out for a day of fun. When we go to visit my folks in Denver my dad always makes it a point to walk with the kids down to the corner store and buy them a candy or slurpee and then they walk back. My kids never comment on the treat (unless it’s gum, a delicacy for some reason) but comment on the time spent together.
Comment #18 by NatalieJanuary 16th, 2007 at 4:51 pmwe have accounts for our kids. we dump money in monthly (even if it’s just a smaaaall amount) and have ONE aunt who knows well enough to just give the kids money for their savings. we minimize what we get the kids because the grandparents spoil them rotten and love every second of it. when we have crazy gift-giving events, we do return gifts and put the money into their accounts. we have five of us in 650 square feet, so there just wasn’t room for the weebles castle and my little pony castle my cousin got our kids for christmas last (never mind that neither of them know who weebles or my little ponies are!). off to target or, um, a similar store they went, mom and dad collected the gift cards to be used for household items, and we transferred the money.
i think it may get easier when the kids get older… my dad goes on and on about when they can start piano lessons (and even bought a piano for his house, though no one plays!) and that could be a gift. mom’s the same way about dance classes. our friends’ parents do that and love it, especially when recital time comes along.
Comment #19 by makakonaJanuary 17th, 2007 at 4:20 pmMy niece has soooo many toys… and $1500 in the bank. She’s 18 months old. My brother got everyone on board for the college fund when she was a boring tiny baby, and now that she’s old enough to go crazy over toys, she gets both.
Comment #20 by MelanieJanuary 17th, 2007 at 9:01 pmTracy M, Nancy, and anyone else looking for help with college savings. We just launched Freshman Fund to try and solve exactly this problem. It’s a registry for your college fund. My name links to the site, and I encourage you to check it out!
Comment #21 by Jonah KeeganJune 3rd, 2008 at 12:31 pm