By Heather O.
This is a guest post by Starababa.
It seems to be a universal truth that almost from the moment of conception, most girls want to be in love. And to exacerbate the problem, they seem to fall in love rather easily. I was just reading The Wiz’s profile about how she wants to marry Mr. Darcy and it reminded me of the crush I also had all growing up on a certain fictional character, one I’m sure you’re all familiar with:
The Gilbert from the “Anne of Green Gables” books sounds amazing enough, but I’m specifically talking about the Gilbert from the Anne movies, played by actor Jonathon Crombie. I think “crush” is actually a rather tame word for how I felt about Gilbert. I ADORED him. I was certain that when I was old enough to get married, I would find him and marry him. Of course my little 8 year-old mind never considered the possibility that he might be in his 40’s by that point.
My parents would tease me about someday finding my Gilbert Blythe to marry, and I guess in the back of my head in some tiny place called Denial I realized that I would never be marrying Gilbert and would simply have to find someone a lot like him. But I really grew up with him as the ideal of what I wanted in a guy! He was absolutely perfect to me in every single way.
When I got a little older and was able to recognize that actors played these people in movies, I was still gullible enough at one point to believe the Mormon Myth that the actor who played Gilbert was a member of the Church and that he had tragically died shortly after the filming of Anne of Avonlea. I was determined to die young and marry him in heaven since I’m sure there were no other women for him but me! Okay, I know I’m sounding obsessed now, but I really did love the Anne movies (except for The Continuing Story that came out just a few years ago–why couldn’t they follow the other Anne books by L.M. Montgomery instead of coming up with some dumb story line of Gilbert going off to WWI? Lame and disappointing.)
But I love the fact that we can innocently fall in love with fictional prince charmings until we find our own real one. And I did and am happily married to him now. I’m grateful for having a high ideal of what I wanted to marry because it helped me date good guys in high school and college, and I am grateful that my DH understands that I’m a hopeless romantic and love to see people fall in love. He has actually sat down and watched all of Anne of Green Gables and Anne of Avonlea with me and enjoyed it, too! (Or at least faked it well for my benefit.)
I’m curious who your fictional Prince Charmings were growing up, or are The Wiz and I the only ones who had them? (By the way, it took me a little longer to discover Pride and Prejudice, but once I did Mr. Darcy became one of my favorites as well.)




in college the gals would pile into one of the itty bitty dorm rooms and we’d watch the anne movies, oohing and ahhing over gilbert–or as he came to be known “The Epitomy of Man”
Comment #1 by AlisonMay 22nd, 2007 at 10:43 amof course the newest reincarnation of Mr. Darcy is pretty fetching too!
Gilbert Blythe is totally hot.
Comment #2 by Heather O.May 22nd, 2007 at 10:54 amLet me nominate for your consideration Lord Orville, from Frances Burney’s Evelina
Comment #3 by BillMay 22nd, 2007 at 11:00 amGilbert Blythe was my literary crush of my youth. I didn’t read Pride and Prejudice until I was in my late teens, so Mr. Darcy did not supplant poor Gilbert until then. When I was in Spanish class we got to pick our Spanish names and also come up with a fun fake life too. My imaginary husband was named Gilberto. lol
Comment #4 by Awesome MomMay 22nd, 2007 at 11:01 amYes, Gilbert was a fav. for me and my friends too. . . however, I may have taken the fictional character crush one step further by having crushes on ANIMATED characters. Specifically Prince Eric from The Little Mermaid and Aladdin. Sad but true. And I wasn’t that little either. . .
Comment #5 by MiggyMay 22nd, 2007 at 11:14 amGilbert was right up there for me as well!
My earliest crush was Pa Ingalls, as played by Michael Landon. As an adult, I’ve been rewatching Little House episodes on PBS–he sure has a lot of gratuitous shirtless scenes. Oh my.
Comment #6 by WendyPMay 22nd, 2007 at 11:24 amThey may not have been princes (or gentlemen)… but how ’bout them Newsies?
Comment #7 by AmandaMay 22nd, 2007 at 11:41 amDmitri, from Anastasia.
Comment #8 by StarfoxyMay 22nd, 2007 at 11:54 amoh I LOVED Gilbert, when me and my sister were little and would play “being married” we both wanted to be married to him. I haven’t read P & P but I guess if he can out do Gilbert I’ll have to give it a read. And my DH sat through all the Anne movies too, even bought them for me. And he sat and listened to me go over point by point of how the 3rd Anne moive was so wrong, (why did they even bother to make it).
Comment #9 by moddyMay 22nd, 2007 at 12:07 pmGene Kelly was my begin-all/end-all crush growing up. Never mind that he was old enough to be my GRANDPA. Ahhhhh, Brigadoon, the music, the faux Scottish countryside, the KILTS. Mmmmmmmm. I’ve got to get it on DVD!!
Love Gilbert too. What other man could put up with so much drama? 3rd, Anne movie was definitely a stinker, shouldn’t have bothered producing it!!
Comment #10 by All8May 22nd, 2007 at 12:38 pmGilbert’s a good choice. I think I also had a crush on Teddy from Little Women. And Ponyboy from the Outsiders.
Right now, it’s Maksim from Dancing With the Stars.
Comment #11 by Susan MMay 22nd, 2007 at 12:47 pmWell, I loved Gilbert, but Jamie Fraser of Outlander does it for me big time. Although I admit a certain partiality to Pip in Great Expectations, he was an outstanding man. And then there is my all time fictional love, Luke Skywalker. I was head over heels in love with him. From the first moment he walked out and spoke to Aunt Beru I was hooked. The summer of 1977 was magical, I spent practically every day in the theater, or at least reading and re-reading Star Wars. When I met Mark Hamill he was wonderful and kind to this teenage obsessed fan, I told my dh if Luke ever appeared, I am outta here! And the Prince in Beauty and the Beast deserves an honorable mention. The beast was pretty hot after he transformed. But then I always loved the red heads. Oh wait, one more, Nicholas Nickleby.
Comment #12 by pollyMay 22nd, 2007 at 12:48 pmAlthough I admit a certain partiality to Pip in Great Expectations…
My first anonymous online “name” was Estella. Haha… Loved Pip.
Comment #13 by WendyPMay 22nd, 2007 at 12:51 pmOh so many men, so little time. Mr. Darcy (or rather Colin Firth) ranks right up there, but then again in my younger years, so did Johnny Quest (o.k. so I’m showing my age). Got to agree with Polly on Jamie Fraser from the Outlander series, and add both Ramses and Emmerson from Elizabeth Peters’ Amelia Peobody series. And then there’s Joe Morelli and Ranger from Janet Evanovich’s Stephanie Plum books. Oh baby does that Ranger do something for me . . .
Comment #14 by jamisueMay 22nd, 2007 at 1:14 pmI love Gene Kelly, Brigadoon was so good, as was Singing in the rain. But I also loved Howard Keel in Seven brides for seven brothers though the actor that played Benjamin was pretty hot too. The actors in those older moives were pretty good looking, Cary Grant, Rock Hudson, etc. Oh and I loved Danny Kaye, not that he was particular cute, just really funny.
Comment #15 by moddyMay 22nd, 2007 at 1:14 pmGilbert…Darcy…Prince Phillip from Sleeping Beauty…Kirk Cameron from Growing Pains (I was 7)…Newsies (YES! I love Newsies! All of them!)…the Beauty and the Beast Prince…and that guy in the Heidi sequel.
Comment #16 by cherylMay 22nd, 2007 at 1:16 pmI had forgotten all about Benjamin. Love redheads. He’s definitely a cutie!!! Good thing I’ll never have to choose, I can watch them both.
Comment #17 by All8May 22nd, 2007 at 1:20 pmI LOVE Johnny Depp!! I also love Hugh Grant and Alan Rickman in Sense and Sensibility. I also liked Hugh Laurie in that too…I think it’s those British accents that get me every time. Too bad my husband went to Finland on his mission…it’s just not the same thing.
Comment #18 by fluffychickyMay 22nd, 2007 at 1:29 pmhaha. Love this thread. All of you will probably get a kick out of Shannon Hale’s new book, Austenland. It’s about a woman who is obsessed with Mr. Darcy, as played by Colin Firth. It’s an enjoyable read. It will be available in a couple weeks, I think.
Comment #19 by EmilyMay 22nd, 2007 at 1:38 pmMy literary prince charming was Theodore Lawrence, of Little Women. My screen prince charming was Fred Savage, little Kevin Arnold of the Wonder Years.
Comment #20 by KermitMay 22nd, 2007 at 1:38 pmBo Duke of the Dukes of Hazzard (aka John Schneider). I did the Walk-a-Thon for him. All 20 kilometers. He flew in to the University Mall in a helicopter to kick off the walk. Ahhhh…
As for “real person” crushes, I cannot get enough of Denzel Washington’s great teeth and smile. Mmm Mmm.
My friend had it for “Potsie” from Happy Days.
Can you tell I wasn’t a very literary youth?
Comment #21 by StrollerbladerMay 22nd, 2007 at 1:42 pmI fell in love with Gilbert in the books. He was this progressive, smart guy who could handle a strong woman. I loved loved loved the books, but thought the movies were really lame…sorry. Other literary crushes? Yes, Teddy in Little Women. And, embarassingly, a couple of Work and the Glory characters, though its been so long I don’t think I remember any of their names. Oh two of them, Will and Peter. Lol, I’m so lame.
Comment #22 by RachelMay 22nd, 2007 at 1:44 pmJean Luc Picard. Fox Mulder. Elliot Stabler. Anything with Dennis Haysbert. From liturature- Rhett Butler- totally swoon-worthy.
I’m so lame.
Comment #23 by Tracy MMay 22nd, 2007 at 1:57 pmGilbert, Darcy-both the old and the new, and Superman as played by Dean Cain. My friend and I were so INFATUATED with him. We would write our own episodes of Lois and Clark.
Comment #24 by AmberMay 22nd, 2007 at 2:02 pmAlmost any character played by Bill Pullman (especially While You Were Sleeping); yes, Gilbert; Magnum P.I. (Tom Selleck) when I was a teenager - anyone know the word twitter-pated?; did I mention Bill Pullman? (what an adorable smile!)
Comment #25 by MIchelleMay 22nd, 2007 at 2:03 pmRemington steel’s Pierce Brosnan (sp) but only him on that show, haven’t really seen anything else of his that I like. And totally like Bill Pullman.
Comment #26 by moddyMay 22nd, 2007 at 2:08 pmOh Gilbert Blythe is just scrumptious!!! I still look at him in the movies and think he’s lovely (which is sick and wrong, as he’s about 19 and I am in my 40s - LOL!!!) Again, love Mr Darcy and also Captain Wentworth from Persuasion (as recently played by Rupert Penry-Jones in the latest adaption - he is scrummy-gorgeous-on-a-stick!!)
But my big crush and the love of my life from the age of 9 was Donny. As in Osmond. *sigh*
Comment #27 by ChrissieMay 22nd, 2007 at 2:25 pm…or that should have been “adaptation” *tsk*
Comment #28 by ChrissieMay 22nd, 2007 at 2:26 pmOh, Picard for sure, Tracy M. Gilbert’s a good pick too.
Comment #29 by Emily M.May 22nd, 2007 at 2:43 pmI always did want Charles to be in charge of ME–Scott Baio was my crush.
Comment #30 by MommymaniaMay 22nd, 2007 at 3:28 pmAforementioned Mr. Darcy, or Colin Firth, I’ll take either one.
Jean-Luc Picard.
Yul Brynner in ‘The King and I’
Basically any of Jane Austen’s main male characters.
Comment #31 by The WizMay 22nd, 2007 at 3:36 pmWesley from “The Princess Bride”! enough said!
Comment #32 by AprilMay 22nd, 2007 at 3:39 pmI remember having a big crush on Roy Rogers as a child. I guess I watched more TV than read …
Comment #33 by JVTMay 22nd, 2007 at 4:07 pmI too had a HUGE crush on Gilbert. I had never read the books before I saw the movie, though, so the two are the same in my mind. *sigh*..Gilbert Blythe…
Bizarrely, I liked Tintin an awful lot when I was quite young.
Comment #34 by dangermomMay 22nd, 2007 at 4:40 pmI loved Gilbert. It’s funny though because I never read the books until last year. I think the movies are way better…Kevin Arnold and I have to second the Bill Pullman comment. I love While You Were Sleeping! and that guy that Drew Barrymore falls in love with in Never Been Kissed. Love him!
Comment #35 by Jamie JMay 22nd, 2007 at 4:50 pmNewsies rocks because Christian Bale is the main Newsie–AND he plays Teddy in the film version of Little Women, AND he is about the sexiest Batman alive, AND he beats out Colin Whathisname (not Firth) for Pocohantas’ love in “A New World” Totally scrumptious.
The guy from Never Been Kissed is also Sydney Bristoe’s true love, Michael Vaughn, from Alias. The guy’s hilarious, or at least seems so from the DVD special features of Alias (my favorite line from the special features is when he says, ‘F— Rimbaldi’. You have to be an Alias fan to appreciate it, but boy, did DH and I laugh!) Yes, he’s totally yummy, too.
Comment #36 by Heather O.May 22nd, 2007 at 5:05 pmCary Grant, and the soothing brogue of Sean Connery. I think I was born about 30 years late!!
Comment #37 by AbbyMay 22nd, 2007 at 6:00 pmAnd Patrick Dempsey cannot be forgotten. As he was and is…
I have to say that I loved Wesley in The Princess Bride, but have you seen the movies he’s done since? He’s always a total dork! How come he got one good role and has never seemed to land one since?
I started thinking more and my other absolute crush from a movie was the guy in “Wild Hearts Can’t Be Broken” named Al. I was so in love with him, and still love that movie to this day (maybe b/c it’s totally clean.)
The other literary crush from recent days is the prince in a juvenile fiction book called Ella Enchanted–such a wonderful book! (The movie is way different and way lame, though.) His name is Char and he’s awesome! My 5th grade students agreed (even the boys loved that book–I highly recommend it if you like children’s lit.)
Oh, and Sandra Bullock even said that she had a crush on Bill Pullman during the making of “While You Were Sleeping”!
Comment #38 by StarababaMay 22nd, 2007 at 6:09 pmI’ll never forget watching the movie “To Kill a Mockingbird” in my high school English class and wondering if any of my friends were having the same heart palpitations. I thought Gregory Peck was so gorgeous and smart. “Gorgeous and smart” were not rampant qualities abounding in boys at my high school.
Comment #39 by ZinkaMay 22nd, 2007 at 6:16 pmQuick male input: My wife (Michelle) and I love to watch While You Were Sleeping because she can drool over Bill Pullman and I can drool over Sandra Bullock.
Comment #40 by RayMay 22nd, 2007 at 6:17 pmI’m definitely going to show my age, here, but Sean Connery’s Bond and Raymond Burr’s Perry Mason were my heart throbs in my younger days. Oh, yes, and my younger sister and I both loved Pat Boone, but I convinced her that the actor Richard Boone was his brother, so if she’d let me marry Pat, she could marry Richard, and we’d both be happy. Evil of me, I know.
Comment #41 by MLEHMay 22nd, 2007 at 6:45 pmCarey Elwes from Princess Bride fame but the movie I liked him in was “Lady Jane.” My sister and I watched that video so often I still have it memorized.
Sting. -Sigh- Still like him.
Kyle MacClachlan as Paul Maudib (sp? not really a Herbert fan) in the movie Dune. At a slumber party when I was 13 we put the video on pause so we could all squeal and ahh at the same time.
Okay, Gilbert!!! The book Gil and the Jonathan Crombie hottie. Teddy. Mr. Darcy. Mr. Rochester from Jane Eyre (though I have yet to see an onscreen Jane Eyre that is as good as I imagined it). Captain Wentworth from Persuasion.
Very embarassing to admit but I actually had a crush on the rat Jeremy in “Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH” (the book not the cartoon). I thought he was hott.
When I was REALLY young Mr. Rogers made me feel all warm and fuzzy like a green knit sweater.
Current faves: Ralph Fiennes, Johnny Depp, Robbie Williams (the singer not the comedian).
Comment #42 by KristaMay 22nd, 2007 at 6:55 pmI am ashamed to confess that I have not read any of the Anne of Green Gables books or seen the movies. I haven’t ever seen Newsies either. And when I read Little Women in eighth grade, I didn’t like it. (I did like the movie with Susan Sarandon and I liked Teddy in that).
I was a horribly unromantic teenager. I didn’t want to get married; I wanted to live by myself on an island working as a marine biologist.
Do I still count as a Mormon mommy?
Comment #43 by FoxyJMay 22nd, 2007 at 7:47 pmKrista, my younger sister said that the new version of Jane Eyre I think done by BBC was really good. And she is really into Jane Eyre.
Comment #44 by moddyMay 22nd, 2007 at 9:18 pmOh to be 10 again!! I LOVE Newsies AND Gilbert! I can re-sight every minute of both. Dances included! While You Were Sleeping is also another one of my absolute favorites, though not so much for the love interests.
Though it seems really lame now, I was totally in love with Johnathan Taylor Thomas, the middle son on Home Improvement. Like Starababa, I totally thought we would someday meet and he would realize how amazing I was and we would live happily ever after. I even gave up meat for 2 years because I heard he was a vegetarian. I can hear you laughing. I’m laughing right a long with you.
Comment #45 by NatalieMay 22nd, 2007 at 9:26 pmThis will show my age, but I had a HUGE crush on JTT (Jonathan Taylor Thomas) when I was in elementary. As a teenager, I had a thing for Val Kilmer from “The Saint.” My husband and I just finished the Alias TV DVDs and I must say that Michael Vaughn is scrumptious! His crooked smile just melts me like butta!
Animated loves- Dimitri from Anastasia tops the list. And then Prince Phillip from Sleeping Beauty.
Comment #46 by CheckersMay 22nd, 2007 at 9:57 pmAhh, Gilbert was a fine one. Al Carver from “Wild Hearts can’t be Broken” - I loved him. Not only was he a hottie, but he was a sweetheart! Nowadays - Hugh Jackman is the one. He is dreamy!!
Comment #47 by BubblesMay 22nd, 2007 at 10:24 pmPeter Wimsey.
Comment #48 by amhMay 22nd, 2007 at 11:09 pmHow could one ever choose between Gilbert Blythe and Theodore Lawrence (of course, as played by Christian Bale)??? Virtually impossible. I dreamt about both of them for a long, long time. Fun post!
Comment #49 by KatieMay 22nd, 2007 at 11:41 pmanother one. Christian Slater in “Bed of Roses” mmmm
Comment #50 by AprilMay 23rd, 2007 at 12:22 amNo one has yet mentioned Ioan Gruffudd as Horatio Hornblower!!! In case you’re not familiar with the A&E series, it’s set in the British Navy during the Napoleanic Wars. Here’s the URL for a picture (but it really doesn’t do him justice - you’ve got to see the movies):
Comment #51 by Mrs MMay 23rd, 2007 at 1:27 amhttp://www.napoleonguide.com/horn_pistol.htm
My literary love has to be Andrew (Ender) Wiggan from Orson Scott Card’s Ender series.
Comment #52 by moniqueMay 23rd, 2007 at 1:54 amI’m more into Gilbert Grape (go johnny go!) I also think Christian Bale is quite nice.
First little girl crush must have been Peter Tork from the Monkees. I don’t think I had any literary crushes - I mainly lived off Mad Magazine and Nancy Drew!
Comment #53 by meemsMay 23rd, 2007 at 2:15 amHey thanks for the tip Moddy.
Comment #54 by KristaMay 23rd, 2007 at 3:59 amGeorge in A Room With a View. I think the DVD is no longer available, which brings me great sorrow.
Comment #55 by Eliza R.May 23rd, 2007 at 5:14 amAll of my crushes were literary for the most part. I had a crush on a faun named Stefan, who was adorable and spoke broken English with a very thick Greek accent, and a thief named Jimmy who was ever so dashing and smart. Neither of the books in question have been filmed so I am completely free to keep my imagined Prince Charmings the way they have always been in my head.
Comment #56 by LATMay 23rd, 2007 at 8:42 amOh goodness - Gilbert, Mr. Darcy and Wesley are all shoo-ins. (Buttercup was SO not worthy!) I would have to add Calvin from Madeline l’Engle, Faramir from Lord of the Rings (books, not movie) and Benedick from Much Ado About Nothing.
Can you tell I am a reading geek?
Comment #57 by SilverRainMay 23rd, 2007 at 8:59 amTure love = being hit over the head with a slate and then APOLOGIZING! You gotta love that Gil
Comment #58 by MelissaMay 23rd, 2007 at 12:14 pmFor all you Anne and Gilbert fans, click on the link below to see a darling recap of all Gil’s and Anne’s moments (except they left out some of the best parts like when Gil picks up Anne in his wagon and asks her to go to the White Sands Recital with him, and when Gilbert and Anne run into each other again and Gil tells her he’s engaged and Anne realizes she really does love him and she follows him to the train station! That’s one of the greatest moments of the whole movie! The person who made this must not really know it that well after all.
)
>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_aPqzcFf7K0
Comment #59 by StarababaMay 23rd, 2007 at 1:12 pm“Very embarassing to admit but I actually had a crush on the rat Jeremy in “Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH” (the book not the cartoon). I thought he was hott.”
I, too had a thing for Jeremy (bought the movie for my kids just for the reminiscence…) and my other cartoon fave was Robin Hood (the fox).
Comment #60 by Natalie S.May 23rd, 2007 at 1:41 pmThere are a few current “yummies” that I watch: Gerard Butler (Phantom of the Opera & Dear Frankie), Dr. McDreamy, Matthew McConaughy. I can watch those 3 over and over again. Great eye-candy, I think!
When I was younger I liked Gene Kelly from Brigadoon as well.
Off to watch Dear Frankie, now…
I also loved most of the Newsies boys, and Benjamin (Jeff Richards according to imbd.com) in Seven Brides for Seven Brothers. When I was little my friends or sisters and I wanted to marry MacGyver.
More recently I really liked Mr. Darcy in the 2005 Pride and Prejudice (especially that scene in the rain when he tells Elizabeth that he loves her). Oh, and I loved Jude Law in The Holiday. Don’t know that I’ve cared for either of those actors in anything else, but loved them in those movies.
Comment #61 by AndreaMay 23rd, 2007 at 4:06 pmPatrick Page
Comment #62 by jbnMay 24th, 2007 at 1:01 pmOk, I didn’t have one growing up, but I do now.
Comment #63 by JessawhyMay 24th, 2007 at 11:33 pmJosh Lyman from the West Wing. (played by Bradley Whitford)
ah, my dreamy political brainy stud muffin
I’m with amh and jamisue: Lord Peter and Ramses or Emerson are just dreamy!
Comment #64 by GuinevereMay 24th, 2007 at 11:43 pmI heartily agree with Gilbert and the rest, but I am
surprised no one has mentioned my pre-adolescent
heartthrob Officer Jon Baker from the show CHiPS. My little
sister and I loved the show and since I called Jon
first, she got stuck with Ponch. We would play
CHiPs while sitting in the car, using
the seat belt buckles as our radios and dreamed of
meeting and marrying our motorcycle riding Prince Charmings.
For some crazy reason, maybe an answer to our young prayers,
Larry Wilcox (the actor who plays Jon) came to visit
our little hometown. My dad must have realized we had
crushes on him and Ponch–could it have been that we
would kiss them on the TV screen when the show intro
came on?–and took us to where he was signing
autographs. My sister and I were both very shy about
it, but when my dad actually told him that we had
crushes on him we about died. I did get an
autographed picture of him in uniform with his
motorcycle so it was all good. Now I live in
California, and my heart still flutters whenever I am
driving down the freeway and see a gleaming gold
helmet pass by.
Oh, and as far as Dancing With the Stars goes, Maksim is great, but I prefer Jonathan Roberts–probably because he subconsciously reminds me of Gilbert Blythe.
Comment #65 by JillMay 25th, 2007 at 2:02 pmWow, I thought I was the only one who had a thing for Prince Philip in “Sleeping Beauty”!
Also:
Comment #66 by Pam W.May 25th, 2007 at 7:44 pmMr. Darcy, of course
Sir Percy Blakeney from “The Scarlet Pimpernel” — noble, smart, adventurous, rich and incredibly romantic!
LAT - Are you describing Jimmy the Hand in Feist’s series? I LOVED him! Did you read David Eddings series? There is also a nice little thief in there.
Comment #67 by jane doughMay 26th, 2007 at 9:35 pmI thought I was the only one in love with Alan Rickman! How about Gary Oldman (NOT Gary Coleman).
Mmmmm. Jean Luc Picard and Mulder.
Ooh, ditto Jean Luc
Comment #68 by AugustineMay 27th, 2007 at 2:17 pm“Energize” baby!